You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Short Attention Span Theater-
James Lileks on the end of Star Trek
2005-05-16
Just the first paragraph and the last.
Hello, all you folks who've never really cared a whit for Star Trek! Goodbye. Our usual mix of petty events and tendentious observations resumes tomorrow. For now: deep into the Geek Sector. Deep. Indulge me, if you want — it's not like this is some insignificant pop culture artifact. Tote all the seasons up, and Trek ran for 28 seasons. It started with LBJ and ended half a decade into the 21st century.

Are we among friends now? Okay.
----------------snip---------------
It ended with the three ships. (Interesting how they didn't show the 1701-E, perhaps because the design wasn't really beloved; it owes too much to the Voyager-class shoehorn look, and the notch on the nacelles looks distinctly unFederation-like. And yes, I just crossed over into the land of unredeemable dorkheadedness, but I'm past caring.) I've always liked the design of the "Enterprise" Enterprise. The 1701-D looks computer generated. But the original ship, the Constitution class — that's the one that still has a hook in your heart. Maybe because it was actually real. They built a model out of wood and painted it and stuck wires in it and filmed it, and those few frames brought the whole story to life. I bought the original model kit and flew it around my bedroom. (I considered buying another and burning it to look like the one in the Doomsday Machine, too.) That was the archetype; that was what Icarus had in mind. And that was what hung in the Smithsonian that day they opened the Star Trek exhibit. All the cast showed up, except for Bones. I met them all: press tour. On the way out I found myself standing next to James Doohan under the big model of the Enterprise, floating above in the hall. I walked up next to Scotty. We looked up.

"Ah, she's a beautiful thing, isn't it?" he said.

That she was.

Posted by:Steve

#4  Please be gentle with me.

I thought Picard was the best of the Enterprise captains just because he was French.

I thought TNG came up with some very unique stories in their own unique way; TNG was the best of the Star Treks.

I know. Blasphemy in Rantburg, so, as I said, be gentle.

Oopsies. Getting my cooke reestablished.
Posted by: badanov   2005-05-16 23:57  

#3  Please be gentle with me.

I thought Picard was the best of the Enterprise captains just because he was French.

I thought TNG came up with some very unique stories in their own unique way; TNG was the best of the Star Treks.

I know. Blasphemy in Rantburg, so, as I said, be gentle.
Posted by: Al Bundy   2005-05-16 23:56  

#2  Still at a loss as to why they're cancelling ENTERPRISE after so short a run - DITTO for EVERYONE LOVES RAYMOND and other shows. ENTERPRISE, etal > NOT GREAT/BEST BUT NOT THE WORST EITHER. IMHO, more Networks + nanoseconds ratings > advantageous for celebrities to stay "typecast", espec iff they want to make acting their careers. Methinks the HollyLeft already know their hoped-for future USSA under Socialist OWG and prioritized deficit spending = America and the world aren't going back to the Moon for another several decades - the LeftLib agenda is good for electioneering and populist schtick, but once in power its out the window!? The HollyLeft focii is getting Hillary elected, iff only for the sake of electing a woman, ANY WOMAN, whom by chance is also a Nazi = Communist, Der Stalin/MarxPanzer "Clinton".
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2005-05-16 23:34  

#1  The older I get, the more and more Trek's Utopian PCness message irritates me. I liked the Original Trek, and it went downhill from there. Though I personally think giving the Enterprise a French Captain was the immediate death knell of the universe. Had Patrick Stewart been given a character with the temper and outlook like he played Gurney Halleck in Dune, it might have been a show worth watching. But to have the flagship of the fleet beaten down by every other race, constantly threaten to self destruct, and characters who seemed more like wooden cutouts than people, I just couldn't stand it.

Ah well, there's always Babylon 5 and Firefly.:)
Posted by: Silentbrick   2005-05-16 23:32  

00:00