You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Tech
Nano No No
2005-09-27
When cutting edge becomes bleeding edge: At first it was feted but now it seems flawed - reports have been growing of problems with Apple's mini music player, the iPod nano.
Specifically, problems have been reported with the colour screens scratching or cracking. It seems questions are being raised about the suitability of the nano for everyday pocket use. At time of writing there are 600 posts on the Apple support forums. The thread 'Apple is going to have to do something about the scratching' details numerous complaints that emerged within a very short timeframe.
Some of them have cracked and broken within a few hours of purchase.

'iPod nano is the biggest revolution since the original iPod,' said Steve Jobs, Apple's CEO at the product's launch. 'iPod nano is a full-featured iPod in an impossibly small size, and it's going to change the rules for the entire portable music market.' Apple has so far declined our requests for comment.
One disgruntled user, reports the BBC, has also set up a website to collate complaints about the nano. He has since been given a replacement player by Apple but remains unmoved. 'I intend to finish what I started and will keep this site going until all users who have cracked LCD's [sic], with no abuse to the Nano, have also been placated by Apple,' he writes on his (homepage.mac) website.
Previously, Apple has faced a class-action lawsuit in the US over iPod battery life. Apple settled in August 2005, to the tune of $15m.
This is why I refuse to be a early adopter anymore. More good customer relation news: Over on Apple's support forums, the company appears to be deleting comments concerning broken iPod nano LCD screens as they appear. Still, one thread dedicated to the iPod nano includes nearly 500 posts chronicling the ease in which the LCD can become severely scratched or damaged. Stock price drop in 5..4..
Posted by:Steve

#10  40 Gigs and I have it 2/3rds full - 8000 songs
Posted by: Frank G   2005-09-27 21:03  

#9  Sman, I still have a Newton. Little slow, little large, but still works well.
Posted by: john   2005-09-27 20:16  

#8  Let's hope Apple gets this resolved well before Christmas shopping. It is an attractive little bugger.
Posted by: Captain America   2005-09-27 18:37  

#7  40G? Damn that's enough for my bridges to no-where collection.
Posted by: abu Wit a Loop   2005-09-27 18:08  

#6  40G Ipod - no problems - leather sleeve case with plastic over the screen plastic - 8 mos - no scratches
Posted by: Frank G   2005-09-27 16:13  

#5  "I" before "e" except after "C". I need to work on it.
Posted by: Mark E   2005-09-27 15:11  

#4  Not true, unless I misunderstand you. There is the very same style white plastic face to the ipod as the old ones. The LCD is not the screen that you can touch; it is underneith the smooth plastic front of the pod. From an angle you can see that the LCD is mounted a few mm beneith the face...I just think that the plastic isn't the exact same one; it just seems much easier to scratch.
Posted by: Mark E   2005-09-27 15:02  

#3  Unlike most other small devices with an LCD screen (and unlike the iPod and iPod mini), the iPod nano has no protective shield over the LCD screen. There's no hard plastic to protect it. Plus, the nano is so thin it flexes a little -- I tried this in an Apple store for myself, and it flexes. LCD screens don't like being flexed.

I love the little sucker, and I'd buy one (white, not black), but the flex issue is enough to stop me. I'll stick with my iPod 4G for now.
Posted by: Steve White   2005-09-27 14:47  

#2  No problem, just store it with your Newton.
Posted by: Shipman   2005-09-27 14:10  

#1  I have one.... The screen is more prone to scratching than other i-pods....
Posted by: Mark E   2005-09-27 12:50  

00:00