You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq
UN: US detains Iraqis in mass arrests
2005-11-15
The United Nations has reported that the US military in Iraq is detaining people faster than a new board can review their cases to determine whether their rights are being respected.
What do they want us to do? Win the war more slowly so they can keep up with the paperwork?
The US-led force continues to hold far more prisoners than the Iraqi government, and most are individuals picked up in mass arrests and detained for "imperative reasons of security," the world body said on Monday. "While progress in reviewing cases led to the release of hundreds, the overall number of detainees continued to increase due to mass arrests carried out during security and military operations," the UN mission said in its latest progress report on human rights, covering the period 1 September to 31 October. "There is an urgent need to provide remedy to lengthy internment for reasons of security without adequate judicial oversight," it said.
I recall reading that one of the Amman boomers was picked up in one of those kinds of operations and released because they didn't have enough to hold him. No doubt the UN thinks there should be more like him.
The number of detainees now held by the multinational force has climbed to 13,514, according to the latest Pentagon figures, up from about 6000 in June and 9600 in September. That is far more than the 7,577 in the custody of Iraq's Justice Ministry, the 3916 held by its Interior Ministry and the 342 juveniles in the hands of its Labour and Social Affairs Ministry as of 26 October, according to Iraqi figures.
Thast's why the Learned Elders of Islam have been squealing like little piggies about our operations. If the Bad Guyz are flowing into the country too fast to catch, that's one thing, but if we're catching them faster than they can be dispatched from Syria, that's something else entirely.
The United Nations has repeatedly expressed concern about the large number of detainees being held in Iraq without apparent due process, alleging that thousands were being held for extended periods without charges or even preliminary reviews to determine whether charges were ultimately likely. The US military insists Iraqi detainees are having their cases promptly reviewed, whether though referral to an Iraqi court or through the new prisoner review board.
Posted by:Fred

#10  for Spiper:
fashion accessories for Spiper

Posted by: 2b   2005-11-15 18:22  

#9  As a US citizen I'm mortified and disgusted by my fellow countrymen's

*snicker*

Hey Spiper, you're a citizen, but you aren't native born, are you? At least for your sake, I hope your tortured language is due to the fact that you learned English with a French or a British accent. Otherwise, you are one raging geek. Do you wear a little bow tie?
Posted by: 2b   2005-11-15 18:19  

#8  Of course, I'm a girl, so technically I can't have any balls. Would the kind gentleman care to move on to a meaningful argument? Thank you.
Posted by: trailing wife   2005-11-15 18:13  

#7  Whew! I was getting a little worried we might not get our Recommended Daily Dose of Clueless ToolFool Finger Waggage. Thanks, Spiper.
Posted by: .com   2005-11-15 14:40  

#6  I think your comments are insipid mewlings from a know-nothing who would rather cower than fight. I don't respect your "arguments" enough to call them un-American, anonymous loser
Posted by: Frank G   2005-11-15 14:39  

#5  As a US citizen I'm mortified and disgusted by my fellow countrymen's apparent lack of regard for the clear truth of the matter - that our military's presence in Iraq is what is causing the numbers of insurgents to grow so rapidly. These are human beings, and we are destroying their homes and lives. Of course they are going to resist. Duh. So would you if you had any balls. If you think that writing this makes me Un-American than I strongly question your definition of what it means to be American. As far as I'm concerned the definition that I'm gleaning from these comments is one that will ultimately lead to our country's economic demise as the nations of the world turn their backs on us in disgust, and rightly so.
Posted by: Spiper Whinetle4938   2005-11-15 14:33  

#4  The guys getting arrested aren't working as waiters.
Posted by: Ptah   2005-11-15 13:04  

#3  "There is an urgent need to provide remedy to lengthy internment for reasons of security without adequate judicial oversight," it said.

I think this means that it's getting harder for them to find a decent waiter in Baghdad.
Posted by: tu3031   2005-11-15 11:40  

#2  The US military insists Iraqi detainees are having their cases promptly reviewed, whether though referral to an Iraqi court or through the new prisoner review board.

Who acntually gives a rat's ass about the UN thinks?
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2005-11-15 11:21  

#1  What do they want us to do? Win the war more slowly so they can keep up with the paperwork? lol!

The US-led force continues to hold far more prisoners than the Iraqi government

I'm not sure, but it appears that they suggesting that we utilize Iraqi methods of dealing with the problem. Well..ok. Hey Mo.. do you know how to drive a back hoe?
Posted by: 2b   2005-11-15 05:44  

00:00