You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Syria-Lebanon-Iran
Merkel Likens Iran Threat to Nazi era
2006-02-04
German Chancellor Angela Merkel likened Iran's nuclear program on Saturday to the threat posed by Germany's Nazi regime in its early days, saying the world must act now to prevent it building the atom bomb.

Addressing the annual Munich security conference, she said there had been complacency in other countries as Adolf Hitler rose to power. "Looking back to German history in the early 1930s when National Socialism (Nazism) was on the rise, there were many outside Germany who said 'It's only rhetoric -- don't get excited'," she told the assembled world policy makers.

"There were times when people could have reacted differently and, in my view, Germany is obliged to do something at the early stages ... We want to, we must prevent Iran from developing its nuclear program."

Post-war Germany, conscious of the Nazis' crimes, has made support for Israel's existence a pillar of its foreign policy. Speaking to an audience that included U.S. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, Merkel had particularly blunt words for Ahmadinejad: "Iran has blatantly crossed the red line," she said.

"I say it as German chancellor. A president who questions Israel's right to exist, a president who denies the Holocaust cannot expect to receive any tolerance from Germany."

Merkel said Iran was a threat to Europe as well as Israel. But she also said diplomacy rather than military action was the way to deal with the threat. "Diplomatic avenues need to be exhausted. We need to hold our nerve, go step by step," she said.
I dunno if diplomatic avenues have been exhausted, they seem more terminal to me.
Rumsfeld, speaking after Merkel, also voiced his support for a diplomatic solution, but said Iran's nuclear program posed a grave threat. "The Iranian regime is today the world's leading state sponsor of terrorism," he said. "The world does not want, and must work together to prevent, a nuclear Iran."
Posted by:lotp

#14  There is not such thing as an "exhausted diplomatic channel".
Posted by: TomAnon   2006-02-04 21:29  

#13  Merkel's comments were solely about the RISE of Hitler - i.e. that there was a time during which he could have been confronted without all-out war, a time in which many chose to ignore the rising danger.
Posted by: lotp   2006-02-04 21:03  

#12  Merkel apperently seems to pay attention to the inteligence briefings she gets. Unlike many world leaders and major political figures.

Diplomacy will be stressed until we are ready to strike. Then we will strike. I don't think this will be like Iraq. No UNSC resolution, no endless debate. It's just going to happen and then we will know it happened.
Posted by: Sock Puppet O´ Doom   2006-02-04 20:48  

#11  If Miss Merkelreally means to equate Iran with Nazi Germany, she needs to review her high school history books. Hitler loved diplomats and diplomacy, because he could keep them happy with conversation and cognac while his armies rolled over his next target. The only thing that stopped Hitler was endless armies fighting against him; and had the diplomats put down their crystal glasses earlier, the required armies could have been smaller. I'm pleased that the good Fraulein noticed, I am not impressed with her logic chain.
Posted by: trailing wife   2006-02-04 20:47  

#10  Diplomacy at this point is like yelling 'DUCK'. It's a little late for words.
Posted by: wxjames   2006-02-04 19:35  

#9  Merkel said Iran was a threat to Europe as well as Israel. But she also said diplomacy rather than military action was the way to deal with the threat.

Diplomacy is operating on credit---sooner, or later, the bill is due.
Posted by: Lord Kalvan   2006-02-04 17:38  

#8  I dig this chick

Me too, but then I had a thing for Maggie in her prime - tough, smart babes. What's not to like? Ima waiting for Condi to crush the Arabist coalition at State before I bestow my unrecquited love for her. Now, Hillary(!) is an evil beast simply hiding in female form til the time is right to show her true form (Cthulhu).....
Posted by: Frank G   2006-02-04 17:13  

#7  Merkel said Iran was a threat to Europe as well as Israel. But she also said diplomacy rather than military action was the way to deal with the threat.

I'm not sure this gives us cause for celebration.
Posted by: 2b   2006-02-04 17:12  

#6  Good for Germany - I guess there are beginning to be signs of a re-awakening in Europe.

Iran, terrorist sponsoring and hate-spewing, is dangerous like the Nazi's were; the al Qaeda Islamist types continue to show themselves as zealous killers of innocents; and now Muslems, broadly it seems, upset about cartoons but not over the Killers who have become the image of Islam.

Totalitarianism approaches (a new 9th century type), and maybe, just maybe, Eurpoe will see it before it arrives.
Posted by: Hank   2006-02-04 17:06  

#5  What a breath of fresh air.

I dig this chick.
Posted by: PlanetDan   2006-02-04 14:56  

#4  I (heart) her for Valentine's.

A Rummy soul mate with clarity of mind and word.
Posted by: Captain America   2006-02-04 14:12  

#3  The kids saying, "It takes one to know one" holds some truth here. If any nation could talk about building a monster under the nose of the rest of the world it would be Germany. In the strictist form she is also correct in diplomacy is alway the best answer. But there comes a time when the threat becomes real and rational nations take action over diplomacy. Or as Carl Von would say diplomacy just extended it's arm of action. I don't think we are ready yet to take them out, but I think the active duty military RBr's that have more than three years left will probably get to add Iran to their tour list.
Posted by: 49 Pan   2006-02-04 12:52  

#2  Does Godwin's Law count if it's from a German?
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2006-02-04 11:23  

#1  Merkel said Iran was a threat to Europe as well as Israel. But she also said diplomacy rather than military action was the way to deal with the threat.

sigh. It's now or never, Europe.
Posted by: 2b   2006-02-04 10:57  

00:00