You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Down Under
Australian school children cast judgement on Muslims
2006-02-07
MORE than half of Victorian schoolchildren view Muslims as terrorists, and two out of five agree that Muslims "are unclean", a survey has revealed. Just over 50 per cent believe Muslims "behave strangely", while 45 per cent say Australians do not have positive feelings about Muslims.
I'm surprised the numbers are that high after Bali.
These are the preliminary findings of the survey, which aims to measure student attitudes towards the Muslim community. The research was conducted in the second half of 2005 and is based on responses from 551 year 10 and 11 students in Victoria.

Almost half said they had learned "a little" about Muslims and Islam at school, but more than a third said they had learned nothing on these subjects. When asked if schools should teach more about Muslims, 29 per cent of the teenagers said no, and 34 per cent said they did not care.

One of the researchers, Abe Ata, of the Australian Catholic University, said the findings showed a need for educators to develop new ways of promoting multiculturalism among children. "There are very strong signals that there is a chasm between mainstream students and Muslim students," said Dr Ata, a senior fellow at the university's Institute for the Advancement of Research.
Then again, the kids could be educating you about a few things: like multiculturalism, which doesn't work when you force-feed it people.
"Educationalists and policymakers in education should take proactive steps to help create more racial harmony in the classroom and outside it."

Waleed Aly, a member of the Islamic Council of Victoria, said the results were troubling. "What it demonstrates is that Muslims are being viewed in a way that is really subhuman," he said. "The only way you can combat this kind of prejudice is on a personal level. It's much harder to hate people when you know someone in that social group."
Perhaps teaching a little self-control would help, eh?
Phong Nguyen, the chairman of the Ethnic Communities Council of Victoria, described the survey's findings as "a wake-up call". "We cannot assume that our children who grow up in a multicultural setting will automatically be accepting of each other," he said.
People need to earn respect, whether as kids or as adults. You can teach kids to start off treating a person they encounter with decency, but the only they'll continue to treat that person with respect is if that person earns it. Somehow that isn't on the multi-cultural agenda.
"Adults need to do things to make sure that our impressionable young children have a growing, mature understanding of the world and other people."

Learning about other faiths and cultures was just as important to a child's education as studying subjects such as maths or physics, Mr Nguyen said.

The Victorian Government's draft new education laws explicitly permits the teaching of comparative religion in public schools, and enshrines values of "openness and tolerance". However, according to the Australian Education Union, while some schools discussed issues involving Muslims within the curriculum, others are more hesitant to do so. "Sometimes schools do shy away from such controversial issues because of the sensitivities," said the union's branch president, Mary Bluett. "There's always the thought that you might fall foul of politicians or parents."

But Andrew Blair, the president of the Victorian Association of State Secondary Principals, said schools had a social responsibility to discuss such sensitive issues with students. "Just because it's tough, you shouldn't turn your back on it," he said, adding that the task of helping young people learn about other cultures lay not only with schools, but also with parents. "The lack of understanding and generosity out of these (survey) results is incredibly disappointing," Mr Blair said.
Posted by:Oztralian

#17  
Every non-mohamedan should be required to read the Koran, preferably one that has not been sanitized for Western consumption, and still retains all of its Islamic goodness.

Posted by: Flaitle Snomong3190   2006-02-07 14:43  

#16  Other questions not published: 89% of the kids do not like the smell of camel manure muslims use as colone, 7% think muslims are humans from this planet, 100% of the girls did not want to be child raped by old men like Muhammad's 9 year old wife Ayesha, 11% think Islam is the religion of peace, 89% think Islam is the religion of piss.
Posted by: Snoger Omainter7215   2006-02-07 14:15  

#15  and this despite the best efforts of SBS world news to de-islamicise any muslim violence (by calling rioters "believers" instead of Islamists for example) and by including pro-Muslim editorial content designed to contextualise WHY muslims might be offended and to justify their position.

God bless the rationality of youth.

Now I wonder if SBS will stop broadcasting the news at all? I mean every night it features muslims killing someone.

just think if there were no muslims there'd be almost no world news of riots/violence.
Posted by: anon1   2006-02-07 12:01  

#14  95% confidence that they may be 8.8% off isn't as bad as I thought. Normally they shoot for over a thousand sample size. Why go lower? Lazy, Cheap?
Posted by: rjschwarz   2006-02-07 11:17  

#13  A 500 sample size gives an error margin of +-4.4% at a 95% confidence level.
Posted by: ed   2006-02-07 10:37  

#12  It's much harder to hate people when you know someone in that social group.

But in your case, we'll make an exception.
Posted by: BH   2006-02-07 10:34  

#11  Muslims "are unclean"? WTF? Unclean is a term Muslims use for others, I've never heard it used by any Westerner to describe anyone. Filthy perhaps but not unclean.

551 is a pathetic sample size as well.

So who wrote/pushed this survey and why? Was it the Australian Catholic University? Is Mr. Ata a Catholic or simply an employee with an unfortunate last name? Enquiring minds want to know.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2006-02-07 10:29  

#10  "Educationalists and policymakers in education should take proactive steps to help create more racial harmony in the classroom and outside it."

Run Away....Ruunnn Awayyyy!
Posted by: DepotGuy   2006-02-07 10:02  

#9  Is that right, Phil? Close to 40%?
Posted by: Grunter   2006-02-07 09:48  

#8  The good news (relatively speaking) is close to 40% of Australian kids are enrolled in private schools of various types (and strongly promoted by the Howard government), and the public school system is in serious crisis.

Otherwise, "Out of the mouths of babes and sucklings"
Posted by: phil_b   2006-02-07 09:14  

#7  Howard needs to do something about his Margo Kingston reading multi-cultis. Their day is past. Send them to Norther Ireland, perhaps.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2006-02-07 09:13  

#6  Maybe we should be like the little children.
Posted by: Besoeker   2006-02-07 07:30  

#5  a need for educators to develop new ways of promoting multiculturalism among children.

This is sickening!
This translates as "we need to brainwash the kiddies so they don't think by themselves, but follow the Party line".

School systems have been failing *everywhere* in the western world, because it has morphed from a teaching system designated to promote learning and education into a mind-formating machine designated to enforce a certain set of neo-marxist values.

I only know of the *totally bankrupt* french school system, but IIUC, this is the same in the USA, Canada, Germany, and I'd guess elsewhere : achievements have been falling miserably compared to early 20th century students, in reading, mathemathics, and others fundation subjects.

Western schools are ridden with gramscists, bent on enforcing the Frankfurt school's program of countervalues.

We're wasting away our collective future. We don't need pedagogues nor educators, we need teachers.
Posted by: anonymous5089   2006-02-07 07:23  

#4  50 per cent believe Muslims "behave strangely"...

LOL! They sure phreakin do!!
Posted by: Howard UK   2006-02-07 07:11  

#3  The kids are smart and gonna be alright. Please Australians, keep the multiculti Stalinists away from your children.
Posted by: ed   2006-02-07 02:37  

#2  
No, we will train your Children
@

The Children's Madrasa Institute
[public schools]

Emersion islam.

Inclusivness ME concerns.

Appreciate the new kind of patriotism. [treason]

Sensitivity to islam's sacred icons.

New historical truthiness.

Celebrate the differences then change to our way or hit the hiway.

Acceptance of the ummah's pain or else.

Posted by: Madrasa Oz   2006-02-07 01:46  

#1  Would love to see the results of the exact same poll taken with Palestinian school children.
Posted by: Snuns Thromp1484   2006-02-07 01:45  

00:00