You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
US journo trapped in Afghan prison riot
2006-03-01
And his captors want his head. This may shed some light on the lack of heavy artillery at the prison site.
An American journalist inmate at an Afghan jail block seized by prisoners said Taliban militants held there threatened on Tuesday to behead him and told him he would die if an attempt were made to end the siege by force. Emmy award-winning documentary maker Edward Caraballo, 44, from New York, was one of three Americans jailed in 2004 after being convicted of running a private jail and illegally detaining and torturing men in a freelance war on terror.

Speaking by mobile phone from Pul-i-Charkhi jail on the outskirts of Kabul, Caraballo told Reuters he was barricaded in his room in block one of the prison, parts of which were overrun by inmates on Saturday night. He said some prisoners in the block were protecting him but others, who said they were Taliban militants, had threatened to kill him if their demands were not met.

"I'm not letting anyone in, and I am not going out," said Caraballo who sounded frightened. "I have told the U.S. embassy that they want to speak to the ambassador and President Karzai on the phone to tell them their demands. I was told that if they don't do that and they don't want to talk to these people, then they will cut my head off. Right after I spoke to the embassy, four of them walked into my room and very calmly, very matter-of-factly, said this is not anything personal against you, but we have grievances that we want to get across to somebody in charge."

The men who threatened him said they were Taliban, not al Qaeda militants, he said. They had said authorities should not attempt to storm the jail.

"They said there would be a lot of bloodshed and I would be one of the first to go," he said. Caraballo said his two-year sentence expired in four months and all he wanted to do was to return home and see his daughter.

"PLEASE, PLEASE, DO NOT STORM"

"My recommendation to the U.S. government and Afghan police force is please, please, do not storm at this time; just keep the negotiations going and please do not attack us," he said. Caraballo was contacted in the prison on a mobile phone number that a diplomat confirmed belonged to the prisoner. He said he had spoken to the U.S. embassy and asked for assistance, but had been told: "They cannot extract me, it is not their business, and it's in the Afghan's hands."

Caraballo said he had been nicked in the side by a bullet or a piece of shrapnel when police opened fire in the prison at the start of the siege, when he had been trying to run back to his cell. He said he was not badly hurt. "It's a nick; it's really nothing," he said. "It was not intentional. The police have been very good in trying to protect me -- it was just friendly fire."

He said he was now feeling unwell and had been vomiting frequently and questioned whether his food had been poisoned. Caraballo said that since the siege began he had been treading a thin line between being one of the protesting prisoners and "being a hostage, because the first thing they said was 'Get the American and get his phone.'"

He said there were about five different factions among the prisoners, one of which was trying to protect him. Caraballo said one of the men who had threatened him had said their only demand was not to be prosecuted for the uprising because the police had started it and killed their comrades. Four prisoners were killed in attempts to subdue the riot.

The two Americans jailed with Caraballo -- Former U.S. Green Beret Jonathan "Jack" Idema and another ex-serviceman, Brent Bennett -- are in the same prison but in a separate block, where they were not thought to be in danger.
Oh my. What a dreadful situation. I presume they planned this uprising with his cellphone in mind.
Posted by:Seafarious

#14  I read this clown had the AQ guys take him to see the other clown, Idema, and then decided he wanted to be kept seperate, guess the AQ treated him better. They took him back to his cell. This is a case of Bevis and Butt head visit Afghanistan. Barb, keep your meeter clear of this on or it might break trying to find a neg reading!!
Posted by: 49 Pan   2006-03-01 19:50  

#13  
US journo trapped in Afghan prison riot
Can't decide whether to file this under "couldn't happen to a more deserving clown" or "who gives a shit?"

Guess I'll wait for my sympathy meter to come back from its annual cleaning before making a final decision.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2006-03-01 19:31  

#12  Hey, Idema's the more controversial...
Posted by: Hupeash Cleart9965   2006-03-01 09:51  

#11  Tried to find out what his "documentaries" are, can't find his name on IMDB.
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2006-03-01 09:35  

#10  OT #5. So, SPoD, you have your own blog site now. We'll drop by from time to time to see how it goes.
Posted by: GK   2006-03-01 09:21  

#9  It's over: Four-Day Riot at Afghan Prison Ends
Posted by: ed   2006-03-01 09:21  

#8  I'm puzzled by the fact that Caraballo has a working cell phone in his cell.
Posted by: GK   2006-03-01 09:04  

#7  Try stuporpatriots.blogspot.com For more on our hero's Ha
Posted by: 49 Pan   2006-03-01 04:30  

#6  Agreed, this guy and his pal Idema are there because they are shisters and wanna be's. Hope they are having fun. Sleep with rats you will get fleas!!!!
Posted by: 49 Pan   2006-03-01 04:16  

#5  I had to bang my sympathy meter a few times to see if the needle was stuck. It's not so I must have no sympathy.
Posted by: SPoD   2006-03-01 03:29  

#4  This guy is an idiot. He's one of those tools who thinks that he's special forces, or something, and sniffs around until where he shouldn't be until he gets into real trouble.
Posted by: gromky   2006-03-01 03:06  

#3  "Nothing personal, but we may have to cut your head off."
"That's not personal?"
"No, no, of course not. It's just a negotiating tactic."
"Yeah, it's good to have an infidel or two around when there are talks."
"Yep. Just don't take it personal, mmmkay?"
Posted by: .com   2006-03-01 02:11  

#2  This site is monitoring the riot hour by hour. I dunno how reliable it is, but go read and decide for yourself.
Posted by: Seafarious   2006-03-01 02:02  

#1  Here is a November 2005 interview with Mr. Caraballo. I hope you all read it; I may even put it up here as a post in the morning.
Posted by: Seafarious   2006-03-01 01:59  

00:00