You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Espying the Jew
2006-08-25
MARK STEYN
Earlier this year, I chanced to be at a public meeting with the great Caroline Glick of the Jerusalem Post. Afterwards, a gentleman from the audience casually made some allusion to some or other aspect of the Jewish calendar, at which I looked momentarily befuddled. And so Caroline helpfully explained to him that “Mark’s not a Jew, but he plays one on TV.”

By which she meant that, as I publicly “defend” Israel (which is, in itself, a curious formulation, implying that the issue is the legitimacy of the Zionist Entity) and as I have a suspiciously Jewish-sounding name, I’ve been routinely assumed, at least since 9/11, to be a Jew. I’m honored to be so mistaken. And, in truth, even if I weren’t, there’s not much I could do about it. Someone asked me on the radio in Australia, two-thirds into a long, long discussion, about how Jewish I was, and I answered that the last Jewish female in my line was one of my paternal great-grandmothers and that both my grandmothers were Catholic. I then filled in a bit of remaining family background for the two or three Aussies who hadn’t yet expired from total boredom. And, of course, I’d only been off the air for ten minutes before I was deluged with e-mails triumphantly announcing, “Ah-ha, something to hide, have we, Steyn? Or should I say Stein? Or is it Goldstein? Why so defensive about being Jewish, eh? How come you don’t have the guts to declare your Jewishness every time you write about Israel? Or do your Jewish media masters encourage you to lie to your readers?”
Posted by:Fred

#11  BTW Rob, what's the 'Buchanan right'?

The "paleocons". The nativists, the isolationists, the racists who don't mask their positions with Marxist cant.
Posted by: Robert Crawford   2006-08-25 17:54  

#10  As far as most Muslims are concerned, all the rest of us are Jews.

Congratulations, Anguper Hupomosing9418, that pretty much nails it.
Posted by: Zenster   2006-08-25 13:47  

#9  As far as most Muslims are concerned, all the rest of us are Jews.
Posted by: Anguper Hupomosing9418   2006-08-25 12:29  

#8  Oh, and he isn't Republican either.
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-08-25 12:13  

#7  Color me Jewish, then. BTW Rob, what's the 'Buchanan right'? He's no more right than I am left. He's just a neo-nazi holocaust denier, who for some reason has been allowed to pose as right-wing on talking head shows.
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-08-25 12:13  

#6  If I wrote 'So you're a Jew are you ?' to someone,
I would think I was actually writing 'I'm a stupid jackass.'
Posted by: wxjames   2006-08-25 10:50  

#5  You can't tell anything by last names anymore. One of the local synagogues regularly posts the names of their newest bar mitzvah boys and bar mitzvah girls on their billboard as congratulations messages. Latest one was a kid named Zachary Antonelli or something like that.

But, like Steyn, the Tsar and I consider it an honor to be occasionally mistaken for Jews even though we're not (the Tsar's last name sounds Jewish and we live in an area in Florida with a few synagogues scattered around).

so if being a Jew disqualifies someone from having a valid opinion on Israel, shouldn't being a Muslim do the same?

Nah, that makes his argument valid, since obviously he's been oppressed by the evil Jooooos, even if he grew up a spoiled rich kid in California or London and barely speaks any Arabic.
Posted by: Swamp Blondie   2006-08-25 08:59  

#4  [i]It never occurred to me to think about such a thing.[/i]

This isn't really anything new to me. Back in college, in '91 or '92, we had a Usenet system that was restricted to campus. Got into a lot of arguments there, and one particular argument was over Israel's right to defend itself against terrorism. A particularly fervent lefty, coming to the defense of the poor, oppressed Palestinians (who would have murdered this fellow for how he lives his life and for what he believes), called me a Jew because I thought it was a good thing to fight against people who shoot up buses, grade schools, etc.

So here's a fellow who would declare himself completely free of racism, bigotry, etc., yet unable to separate support for Israel from being Jewish. It's as if you assumed anyone who had opposed apartheid was black, or that anyone who wants a free Tibet is a Tibetan.

If anything, the crap's gotten worse over the last fifteen years. The left (and the Buchanan right) has rendered itself incapable of thinking in regards to Israel; to the point where they not only accept, but defend even the clumsiest propaganda and conspiracy theories.
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2006-08-25 08:03  

#3  It never occurred to me to think about such a thing.
Posted by: trailing wife   2006-08-25 07:38  

#2  so if being a Jew disqualifies someone from having a valid opinion on Israel, shouldn't being a Muslim do the same?
Posted by: PlanetDan   2006-08-25 07:10  

#1  Fooled me.
Posted by: Snease Shaiting3550   2006-08-25 00:22  

00:00