You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Britain
British officer resigns over 'clumsy' Afghan war
2006-09-11
LONDON: An officer has resigned from the British army in protest its "grotesquely clumsy" campaign against the Taliban in Afghanistan, a newspaper reported on Sunday. Captain Leo Docherty was aide-de-camp to Colonel Charlie Knaggs, a senior commander in the British task force in southern Afghanistan but quit last month after becoming disillusioned with its strategy in Helmand province, The Sunday Times said. The approach is "a textbook case of how to screw up a counter-insurgency," Docherty was quoted as saying. "All those people whose homes have been destroyed and sons killed are going to turn against the British," he said.

"We've been grotesquely clumsy. We've said we'll be different to the Americans who were bombing and strafing villages, then behaved exactly like them," he said. "We've deviated spectacularly from the original plan," Docherty was quoted as saying. "The plan was to secure the provincial capital Lashkar Gah, initiate development projects and enable governance. During this time, the insecure northern part of Helmand would be contained: troops would not be sucked in' to a problem unsolvable by military means alone," he explained.

Docherty said the plan "fell by the wayside" because of pressure from the governor of Helmand, who feared the Taliban were toppling his district.
Posted by:Fred

#24  The Donks would nominate him for president.
Posted by: SR-71   2006-09-11 17:29  

#23  Good thing he's not an American, the Donks would make him man of the year!!
Posted by: 49 Pan   2006-09-11 16:55  

#22  Helmands didn't bring out the best.
Posted by: 6   2006-09-11 13:14  

#21  Cya, you damn REMF.

Make damn sure than ANY terrorists are killed quickly and without allies casulaties and you will find that the rest have a sudden intrest in harvesting their crops or something besides fucking with your forces.

Dipwad.
Posted by: DarthVader   2006-09-11 11:21  

#20  A staff officer, enough said.
Posted by: gromgoru   2006-09-11 10:19  

#19  Captain Clumsy needs to read David Warren:

This single fact strikes me as the key to allied victory. It is to make the price of “going Western” very low, and the price of “going Taliban” very high, and let the hearts and minds sort themselves through the bargain.
Posted by: john   2006-09-11 10:11  

#18  Don't let the door hit ya, Chauncy.
Posted by: mojo   2006-09-11 10:11  

#17  Just added it to my Amazon shopping cart. Thanks guys.
Posted by: Steve White   2006-09-11 09:51  

#16  Indeed it was.
Posted by: Besoeker   2006-09-11 08:42  

#15  Oh, wait -- she wrote Far Pavilions, right? Yes, I read that - wonderful book.
Posted by: lotp   2006-09-11 08:12  

#14  No, I haven't -- thanks for the ref!
Posted by: lotp   2006-09-11 08:08  

#13  Lotp, ever read any M.M. Kaye? She says a lot about India and the region in her writings. Splendid female author, my personal fav.
Posted by: Besoeker   2006-09-11 07:55  

#12  All those people whose homes have been destroyed and sons killed are going to turn against the British," he said.

Unlike the last time we Brits had troops in the Hindu Kush.
Posted by: lotp   2006-09-11 07:47  

#11  And cuz I've turned over a New Leaf™ thingy.

Yeah, right. And monkeys shooting bottle rockets are gonna fly outta my butt, too.


Well there has been an absense of the brazen graphic adornments. But then we now have the etherial Page One Girls of the Defender-Scimitar.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2006-09-11 07:43  

#10  "All those people whose homes have been destroyed and sons killed are going to turn against the British," he said.

Very well then oh wise and learned counterinsurgent expert. Then would you say Captain, they were your allies before you arrived?
Posted by: Besoeker   2006-09-11 07:23  

#9  "All those people whose homes have been destroyed and sons killed are going to turn against the British," he said.

What's the threat from a buncha homeless women?
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2006-09-11 07:23  

#8  And cuz I've turned over a New Leaf™ thingy.
I certainly hope not.
Posted by: SR-71   2006-09-11 07:07  

#7  And cuz I've turned over a New Leaf™ thingy.

Yeah, right. And monkeys shooting bottle rockets are gonna fly outta my butt, too.
Posted by: Zenster   2006-09-11 06:28  

#6  I refuse to answer on the grounds that the Sink Trap is dirty and scummy cuz of some of the previous occupants. And cuz I've turned over a New Leaf™ thingy.
Posted by: .com   2006-09-11 03:35  

#5  Because, as we all know, Americans are just grotesquely clumsy.

There, can I go home now?
Posted by: gorb   2006-09-11 03:29  

#4  Goddamned American Cowboys. He has a plan and a better way. Soft power. This mantra has become a Western, if not global, meme. I note that its failures, such as the clusterfuck in southern Iraq, never get full coverage / equal billing. I'm glad this dink is quitting.
Posted by: .com   2006-09-11 03:18  

#3  I guess the good captain was never taught the old "No plan survives contact with the enemy" thingy. Notice also the offhand slander against the U.S. So long, cap. Don't let the door hit you in the ass...
Posted by: PBMcL   2006-09-11 01:21  

#2  Their damn it not there. Hehehe I never proof read; it's my downfall.
Posted by: Sock Puppet of Doom   2006-09-11 01:16  

#1  I am sure your fellow officers are glad to see you go, but the BBC will hire you as an 'expert' I am sure. You didn't like killing the Taliban and there supporters too bad now FOAD.
Posted by: Sock Puppet of Doom   2006-09-11 01:15  

00:00