You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq
Two years after U.S. assault on it, Fallujah returns to insurgent hands
2006-11-09
FALLUJAH, IRAQ - When insurgents hid a bomb in front of his house a few days ago, intending to use it against U.S. or Iraqi troops, Majeed al-Rawi had only one option: Move out.
"If I report it to the Americans, I will be killed by the men who put it there, and if I don't, my family will be killed either by the explosion or the Americans," the car dealer said. "This is not a way to live; this is a way to hate life."

Two years after U.S. troops launched a devastating ground assault that purged, at least temporarily, the heart of the Iraqi insurgency, Fallujah once again is a violent place.

In recent months, insurgents have filtered back into the city, despite tight controls that limit access to only six checkpoints. Residents must submit to an extraordinary identification system that includes fingerprinting, retina scans and bar-coded identification cards.

An insurgent intimidation campaign has killed two City Council members and at least 30 police officers.

The campaign has been so effective that police patrols have all but stopped, as officers fear to walk the streets.

The number of shootings, bombings and bombs found and defused has doubled since last winter, to about four or five a day, U.S. officers say. There have been about half a dozen car bombings in recent weeks.

Residents and police alike complain bitterly that after two years security is eroding in what had been a U.S. success story.

"Bush didn't give us democracy, he gave us more new ways to be killed," Al-Rawi said. "I think there is no future anymore. I believe the only future is to leave this country. "We can win the war, but for now Al-Qaida has won in Fallujah," said a police officer who didn't want his name used for security reasons. "They made the police force stop patrolling streets, and that's a victory."

Because insurgents target them at home, many officers are living in the police stations. Others simply quit.

"What was I going to wait for that would keep me on the force?" said Muhammad Humadi, a captain who quit in August after one of his commanders was beheaded. "Nothing was going to get any better. I have children, and if I were to sacrifice myself it wouldn't change anything."

With more Americans expressing support for different policies in Iraq, Fallujah offers a lesson in frustration.

Until this August, Fallujah was relatively peaceful, at least by Iraqi standards. But then U.S. forces stepped up a campaign against insurgents in nearby Ramadi and added troops in Baghdad in an effort to quell growing violence there. Some military officers here think that pushed insurgents to Fallujah.

By mid-August, insurgent threats against and assassinations of police officers got so bad that half the police force stayed home for several days. Many quit or moved into their stations.

U.S. and Iraqi troops have nowhere near the manpower needed to take up the slack, said Lt. Col. James Teeples, the senior adviser to the Iraqi Army unit responsible for much of the city.

"We just don't have the manpower to maintain surveillance on the entire city," Teeples said.

Layers of distrust

Other factors contribute to the insecurity. Fallujah is nearly entirely Sunni, and so is its police force. But Shiites dominate the army, which doesn't trust the police force and thinks that insurgents have infiltrated it.

Many residents sympathize with the insurgents. At a clinic last week, word passed down a line of women who were waiting to see the doctor that a sniper had killed a U.S. soldier.

"I wish I'd shot him," one woman said, to the approval of some others.

U.S. commanders remain optimistic. Lt. Col. Jay Bargeron, the second in command of the Marine regiment that works in and around Fallujah, noted, for example, that Iraqis have stepped forward to replace the City Council members killed by insurgents and construction is evident on nearly every street as residents work to rebuild destruction from the November 2004 battle. A little positive news late in the article, editor must have missed it!

Still, the outlook is bleak for police officers, as they recount the slaying of the deputy police chief, the resignation of the police chief and the threats against and killings of other officers.

One officer said, "The future is vague, and I believe the war we are fighting is one of a kind and no one knows what the results might be."
Posted by:GolfBravoUSMC

#23  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:20  

#22  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:20  

#21  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:20  

#20  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:20  

#19  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:20  

#18  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:19  

#17  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:19  

#16  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:19  

#15  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:19  

#14  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:18  

#13  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:18  

#12  
Posted by: George W Bush   2006-11-09 14:18  

#11  Zenster: "S'alright, Frank. Beer, it's not just for breakfast anymore!"

By God that's why I LOVE this site!! :)
Posted by: Justrand   2006-11-09 23:37  

#10  jeebus. gotta quit drinking at breakfast

S'alright, Frank. Beer, it's not just for breakfast anymore!
Posted by: Zenster   2006-11-09 21:51  

#9  Oops, in meant Mpls Star and Cicle
Posted by: Captain America   2006-11-09 21:21  

#8  Minneapolis Star and Cycle? Com'on
Posted by: Captain America   2006-11-09 21:18  

#7  or even, "said"


jeebus. gotta quit drinking at breakfast
Posted by: Frank G   2006-11-09 18:37  

#6  StarTrib - nuff swaid.
Posted by: Frank G   2006-11-09 17:53  

#5  Aint nothing in these towns or cities that a large bombing campaign wouldn't cure.
Posted by: Cyber Sarge   2006-11-09 17:45  

#4  http://www.centcom.mil/sites/uscentcom1/Lists/Press%20Releases/Current%20Releases.aspx
Posted by: Chuck Simmins   2006-11-09 16:24  

#3  Can you please provide link to referenced CentCom release.
Posted by: Shaising Threrelet4176   2006-11-09 16:12  

#2  Mostly BS here. Look at the CentCom press releases for a different perspective.
Posted by: Chuck Simmins   2006-11-09 14:56  

#1  Fallujah may be a damned city. If the local residents cannot keep out the villains, who then attack the government, then there is a good chance the government will replace the citizens with different citizens, who can.

That is, the Sunnis must be convinced beyond all doubt that they must stop all violence in their area, or they will lose their area forever.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2006-11-09 14:36  

00:00