You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
India-Pakistan
Bin Laden more likely to be in a city than a cave: former ISI chief
2007-10-10
Osama bin Laden could hide more easily in a city than a remote tribal region, a former Pakistani intelligence chief said on Tuesday, challenging the notion that the Al Qaeda leader is probably holed up in a mountain cave.
My guess is that he's in Qazi's guest house, and has been since late 2001.
Lt General Asad Durrani, former head of the ISI, said news of outsiders’ presence travels fast in the tribal areas and it would be hard to keep it secret for years. “In the countryside or in tribal areas ... it’s difficult to hide yourself because there people live ... and operate in a manner in which finding out about unusual presence is very important,” Durrani told Reuters in an interview in London. He said it was true that tribal customs placed great value on showing hospitality and not betraying a guest. “In the tribal code, anyone who seeks your protection has to be defended, with your life if necessary.” However, “I am not sure over a period of four, five or six years that it would be possible even for the tribesmen to keep his presence under wraps,” he added.

Such information would have travelled or been divulged, given the incentives, Durrani said in a reference to the $25 million US bounty on bin Laden’s head. “My conclusion therefore is that it’s extremely unlikely that he is around that place.”
Posted by:Fred

#17  My money is on a Pak Army General's mansion inside Rawalpindi cantonment.
Posted by: john frum   2007-10-10 19:19  

#16  There is a captured video where Bin Laden welcomes a Saudi guest and talks about planning the 911 attack.
Inside what is obviously a large house, He greets the guy with a "welcome to my cave" and they both laugh.
Posted by: john frum   2007-10-10 19:19  

#15  He'd dead.
Posted by: Crusader   2007-10-10 17:51  

#14  Nah, my guess is he's cruising the seas. His brother-in-law has been in the Philippines & Indonesia and his younger brother reportedly in South America. Bali and Sharm al-Shek are only a few resort areas either targeted or as meeting spots. Granted it was Debka, but AQ is also said to have its own fleet of ships. His father was a dockworker before he made his fortune in construction and his mother from the port of Latakia in Syria. He left Sudan in his own plane to Afghanistan. I suspect Binny is much more well traveled than anyone has suspected. The cave dweller persona is just more Muslim deception to keep our military busy.
Posted by: Danielle   2007-10-10 14:28  

#13  If Bin Laden was living in Mecca, does anyone believe the kaffir west would ever be told? Even moderate Muslims would do a hand pump at the way Binny gave the finger to the man and they'd keep silent. Perhaps giving some money to the cause.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2007-10-10 14:09  

#12  Dearbornistan more like. Working at a gas station. The chaldeans own the 7/11s.
Posted by: Broadhead6   2007-10-10 13:29  

#11  Detroitistan?
Posted by: Icerigger   2007-10-10 13:19  

#10  He's got a condo on Fire Island which he shares with Castro and a full-time medical staff.
Posted by: Iblis   2007-10-10 12:41  

#9  Look for the tall skinny dead guy with other rabble under rubble somewhere.
Posted by: JohnQC   2007-10-10 11:26  

#8  Has anyone checked camp casey???

Posted by: anonymous5089   2007-10-10 10:22  

#7  Detroit
Posted by: Sheba Phavick4542   2007-10-10 10:00  

#6  He probably lives in Durrani's basement...
Posted by: tu3031   2007-10-10 09:10  

#5  Why Pakistan? He's probably home in Soodia---enjoying a well earned rest in the lap of his family.
Posted by: gromgoru   2007-10-10 07:40  

#4  Osama bin Laden could hide more easily in a city than a remote tribal region

So, is this an indication that we should be bombing all major cities in Pakistan?
Posted by: Zenster   2007-10-10 03:29  

#3  Â“My conclusion therefore is that itÂ’s extremely unlikely that he is around that any place.”
Posted by: twobyfour   2007-10-10 03:14  

#2  I still think it's more likely a hidden rural cave network
Posted by: Victor Emmanuel Unomoting3635   2007-10-10 01:55  

#1  Milwaukee? Chicago?
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2007-10-10 00:10  

00:00