 Kareem Elbayar, Arab News
“O ye who believe! Stand out firmly for justice, as witnesses to God, though it may be against yourselves, or your parents, or your kin, and whether it be against rich or poor: for God can best protect both. Follow not the lusts of your hearts, lest ye swerve, and if ye distort justice or decline to do justice, verily God is well-acquainted with all that ye do.” (Qur’an 4:135)
In a Dec. 7 Op-Ed in The New York Times, Ayaan Hirsi Ali asked where the moderate Muslims were, and concluded that the very notion of a moderate Muslim majority was “wishful thinking”.
| Some of us had come to the very same conclusion. |
Ali’s claims are echoed by many prominent commentators on the American right, and judging by the comments left on The New York Times website, by many average Americans as well. But the popular idea that mainstream Muslims either do nothing to condemn (or worse, secretly applaud) the outrages perpetrated in the name of our religion is not only reductive and misinformed — it is dangerously wrong as well.
The vast majority of the worldÂ’s 1.5 billion Muslims are indeed moderate, peace-loving people who reject violent extremism and terror.
| And we'd appreciate it if they'd get their crazy cousins under control. It would make life a lot easier for all of us. |
Moderate Muslims are all around us, from the attorney and husband of the rape victim from Saudi Arabia; to the delegation of British Muslims who traveled to Sudan and worked with Sudanese member of parliment Ghazi Suleiman to secure the “teddy bear” teacher’s release (and prove that the entire controversy was more about distracting international attention from Darfur than it was about Islam); ...
| ... which illustrates how easily Islam can be used by radicals and crazed killers to divert the attention of, oh, a billion and a half moderates ... |
... to the literally hundreds of thousands of Muslim individuals and organizations in the United States and around the world that expressed shock and disgust at the events which Ali cites.
| And then send money to the Widows Ammunition Fund, since we all know that the most pressing charitable need for the families back in the old country is for more ammunition. The issue here is the disconnect between what the moderates say in public versus what they say in private, and do with their wallets, and with their children ... |
Ali conveniently omits these facts from her narrative — just as she plucks a single verse from the Qur’an, devoid of any context — in order to create a black-and-white fantasy world of Muslim radicals versus civilized Westerners.
| Seems to be a lot of that going around, usually in the finer madrassas in Wazoo, the Frontier, Saoodi-controlled Arabia, Yemen and Hamastan. |
Yes Ms. Ali, verse 24:2 of the Qur’an sets out a harsh punishment for adultery — but verse 24:4 requires four eyewitnesses (an almost impossible standard to meet) and, more importantly, verse 24:5 states that the punishment should not be applied to those who sincerely repent. (So much for your argument that the Qur’an orders believers to show no compassion).
| And so much for convicting a rapist, which some would argue was Mo's point. |
Ali may make headlines by writing polemics condemning Islam as a “backward religion” and “the new fascism”, but in the meantime Muslim organizations like the one I am a member of, Muslims for Progressive Values, will continue to quietly but effectively do what we can to counteract the hateful nonsense that regretfully is being taught as Islam in far too many places.
| If "Muslims for Progressive Values" can persuade moderate muslims to wake up and sit on their crazy cousins, fine and dandy, but I get the sense that it's just another group engaged in a little taqiyya. |
Moderate and even progressive Muslim organizations can be found all over the world, but we are too busy working within our communities to promote a message of reform and tolerance to do as Ali asks and “rise up in horror” every time some lunatic commits a crime in the name of our faith.
| Isn't rising up to condemn atrocities one way to promote tolerance? |
Nor should we be expected to do so.
| Why not? We asked Americans of Irish ancestry not to send money to NORAID. |
It seems that Ali would like me and my co-religionists to go about our lives constantly marching around the streets apologizing for the acts of zealots — but I will not do so, for I bear no more responsibility for these acts than she does.
| You don't have to march in the street following every atrocity. You do have to make abundantly clear that you stand against these atrocities. |
Moderate and progressive Muslims are everywhere, but we are ignored and marginalized by the media and by commentators like Ali.
| Isn't it your job then to speak loudly enough that the MSM and commentators won't ignore you? Seems to me that every advocacy group has that problem. |
It seems that in our modern age of sound bites and one-liners, strident if uninformed criticism will always outperform calm and reasoned debate. If Ali is serious about supporting tolerance among Muslims, perhaps she should spend less time penning distracting and misleading screeds against Islam and more time reaching out to groups like the Council on American-Islamic Relations, Muslims for Progressive Values, Al-Fatiha, and Sisters in Islam.
| If you're grouping yourself with CAIR, then I know what I need to know about you. |
The only way to prevent the “clash of civilizations” from becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy is to build bridges between our communities.
| Which is as much your responsibility as hers, or ours. You can be a Muslim, but you also have to be an American. And it's your responsibility to ensure that the two mesh, not mine. |
Promoting a black-and-white caricature of reality serves no one — least of all the tolerant Muslims Ali can’t seem to find anywhere she looks. |