| Submit your comments on this article |
| -Short Attention Span Theater- |
| Music cannot change the world, says Neil Young |
| 2008-02-09 |
| Canadian folk rock legend Neil Young said he has lost all hope that music can change the world, as he presented a documentary about his 2006 anti-war concert tour at the Berlin film festival on Friday. Welcome to adulthood, Neil. "I know that the time when music could change the world is past. I really doubt that a single song can make a difference. It is a reality," Young told reporters. Don't worry, Neil. A single Nuke going off in Berkeley still could, but I don't know if it would be for the good or the better. "I don't think the tour had any impact on voters." What tour? But the silver-haired frontman of the sixties supergroup Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young nonetheless dealt US President George W. Bush a stinging, back-handed insult and said his own "naive" urge to make people think remains intact. "What is wrong with George Bush? That would take a really long time. Let's talk about what is right with him, it is a much shorter answer. "He is a very good physical specimen. He shows that a man his age can stay in physical condition," said Young, who is 62. He made no distinction between the Vietnam War, during which CSNY first earned their reputation as political activists, and the US-led war in Iraq which their tour condemned with songs like "Let's Impeach The President". It's all just war, man! "It is all the same war and it hurts everybody. It's a wrong way to solve a problem," he said, adding that Americans were deluded if they thought they were liberating Iraq. You're right. You can thank the extremists for dragging us into it. Oh, and the Americans' desire to preserve their way of life. Well, 52% of them, anyway. "We just don't have to go and spread democracy around the world." Wrong tree, Neil. Young said he deliberately included interviews with unimpressed critics and soldiers who served in Iraq and Afghanistan in the documentary of his band's "Freedom of Speech" reunion tour, which earned them both praise and death threats. Picked them at random and they all had the same thing to say, right? "Otherwise I thought it would just feel like a bunch of old hippies. And nobody would care. I would not, I would have left," said Young, who directs his films under the pseudonym Bernard Shakey. Your camouflage didn't work, and the reality is you're still an old hippie. "I wanted to serve the people who came to see the shows, to serve the soldiers who fought in the war and to serve the people who started the war. It sounds naive but everybody has to make a decision in their hearts about how they want to live." Wanna serve the soldiers? Ask their opinion first. Then cater to that. "CSNY: Deja Vu", which borrows its title from an album the band released in 1970, had its world premier at the Sundance Film Festival in January. It is screening in the Berlinale Special section of the Berlin festival, which has this year made music a headline act by bringing The Rolling Stones, Madonna and rock poetess Patti Smith to town. Isn't there some part of the Berlin Wall left standing that you could show it on for some kind of symbolic effect? Martin Scorcese's Stones concert film "Shine A Light" opened the festival with a bang on Thursday night and the Oscar-winning director said he wanted to pay tribute to the vintage rockers as they had inspired his work from "Mean Streets" through to "The Departed." Coming days will see screenings of Madonna's directorial debut, "Filth and Wisdom," movies about Sudanese hip-hop artists and Argentinian tango and "Om Shanti Om", the Bollywood song and dance blockbuster. Patti Smith will attend a screening of a documentary on her career and play a sold-out concert on the festival sidelines. Young, who managed the quirky feat of singing every line of dialogue in his 2003 film "Greendale" said music was a "primal subject" for the movies. But the genre has changed little in his time, he added. "I have not seen tremendous growth, any evolution really. From the Sinatra years, The Who's 'The Kids Are Alright' ... directors have always made films about music culture. There have been some great ones though." |
| Posted by:gorb |
| #9 I disagree that music can't change the world. Bagpipe music used to do a pretty fine job of it. That was before the UK began removing their spines at birth. But of course, Lefty Moonbat music can also change the world. It turns people with brain cells into Republicans. |
| Posted by: Silentbrick 2008-02-09 23:49 |
| #8 From "Let's Roll" to "Let's Run" in how many years? If musicians are so flimsy in their own opinions why the hell should we give them any credit. I think Crosby Stills, Nash and Young probably thought there 4 Dead in Ohio song caused the uproar about that campus shooting, as if nobody would have been offended if there wasn't a theme song guiding them. Music can entertain and it can fill the emptiness but uninformed politics and irrational fears are still uninformed politics and irrational fears even when put to music. I still smirk when I listen to all of those anti-nuke songs from the 80s that always seemed to tilt that it was USA's fault we were spiraling into inevitable war. Yeah maybe people who live the problems day and night knew a bit more about things than those that learned about it from a Time magazine article they skimmed and the feverish rantings of a drug-soaked roadie. Maybe. |
| Posted by: rjschwarz 2008-02-09 10:50 |
| #7 As a baby boomer from a family with many in uniform at the time, I have never forgiven him for this refrain: Tin soldiers and Nixon's coming, We're finally on our own. This summer I hear the drumming, Four dead in Ohio. Gotta get down to it Soldiers are gunning us down ... Watching the shameful abuse of those national guardsmen, spitting and rock throwing and more. And that young kid who panicked and fired and felt awful afterwards ... And then this slimemold makes a fortune off of it with his self-righteous song? SPIT (Not that I feel strongly about it or anything ...) |
| Posted by: lotp 2008-02-09 10:47 |
| #6 The above should read: if I screened my music for moonbats, I'd have practically nothing left |
| Posted by: docob 2008-02-09 10:38 |
| #5 Neil actually was kinda gung-ho right after 9/11, with songs like "Let's Roll". The the hippy instincts kicked in. Neil's made great music. If I screened my music for moonbats, I'd have practically nothing less. Musicians and movie stars and the like are basically overpaid extended adolescents. It's what they do for society ... most of us go and get a job, raise a family, etc ... we pay Neil to facilitate our fantasy that someday we could still learn some bar chords and hit the road. |
| Posted by: docob 2008-02-09 10:35 |
| #4 This southern man don't need you around anyhow. |
| Posted by: Beavis 2008-02-09 10:34 |
| #3 "Music cannot change the world, says Neil Young" It never could, idiot - that was a leftie fantasy from the git-go. And your "music" sucks, too. |
| Posted by: Barbara Skolaut 2008-02-09 10:17 |
| #2 Whiny asshat. |
| Posted by: lotp 2008-02-09 10:15 |
| #1 Young said he deliberately included interviews with unimpressed critics and soldiers who served in Iraq and Afghanistan in the documentary of his band's "Freedom of Speech" reunion tour, which earned them both praise and death threats. Not to be nitpicky, but wouldn't people actually have to see this "documentary" to have that kinda reaction? Although I'm sure it'll be on the Sundance Channel, which plays movies that are so bad that it's part of my basic cable package, soon. "Otherwise I thought it would just feel like a bunch of old hippies. And nobody would care. I would not, I would have left," said Young, who directs his films under the pseudonym Bernard Shakey. Make that "very rich old hippies"... |
| Posted by: tu3031 2008-02-09 09:48 |