You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front Economy
Beijing and Riyadh will call the shots on ailing dollar's future
2008-05-11
Only a month ago the dollar slumped to an all-time low against the euro. And it's just five weeks since the greenback hit a 12-year low against the yen.

But now, the US currency has started to strengthen - with the markets talking about a "turning point". On Wednesday, the dollar reached a six-week high against the European single currency, closing in on $1.53 - an improvement of more than 5 cents. And on the same day, the greenback climbed to a 10-week peak against the pound.

But does the dollar remain in danger? Could "the rope slip" and the world's pivotal currency still go into freefall? That would plunge America beyond recession and into depression - as inflation ballooned amid soaring import costs, forcing the Federal Reserve to raise rates in the teeth of shuddering slowdown.

A plummeting US currency would also cause chaos globally, as central banks sought to protect the value of their reserves. And after the inevitable overshoot, the currency would snap back, sending financial markets into a tailspin, and threatening a fully-blown global slump. That danger has been averted for now, but could soon come back with a vengeance. And while policymakers in Washington will be content with the current situation, those elsewhere shouldn't be.

It's instructive that the main reason for the dollar's "recovery" has little to do with the US economy. The greenback's relative strength is less about the robustness of America, than the weakness of the eurozone. It's been widely assumed Europe has escaped the worst of the credit crisis. And with the exception of UBS et al, the writedowns suffered by Continental banks have been much less than those in the States.

But a slew of bad data has lately challenged such assumptions. Eurozone retail sales fell heavily in both February and March. Last month, the PMI Euro-manufacturing survey dropped to its lowest level since August 2005. New data shows the bellwether IFO index tumbling in April - contrary to market expectations. And in Germany, the eurozone's powerhouse, factory orders have just contracted for the fourth month in a row.

So while the US growth outlook has barely improved in absolute terms, its position now looks rosier relative to the eurozone - which, of course, pushes the dollar up. And while the European Central Bank last week held interest rates at 4 per cent, it's surely only a matter of time before political pressures prevail and euro borrowing costs fall. And, once again, that prospect makes the dollar look relatively more attractive.

As if to help the dollar's recovery, the European Commission last week published some interesting data. The eurozone suffers when the dollar is weak, of course - as its exports are less competitive.

So I smiled when I saw the graph opposite in a Commission report on the 10th anniversary of the euro, showing America's superior growth performance. Eurocrats usually hate admitting the US grows faster than Europe.

But in the current climate, in a bid to reflate the dollar, they're shouting it from the rooftops. Brussels is even prepared to forecast that faster US growth will continue into the medium-term too.

After months of squabbling, not least at last month's G7 summit, an agreement has been struck that the greenback has become so weak it could soon slip into freefall. So, in a co-ordinated move, ECB and Fed officials are now talking the currency up, whispering to journalists and the markets that if the dollar doesn't strengthen there'll be "intervention" - which, for now at least, bolsters the greenback.

But the situation is by no means stable. One reason is that the US has got by far the better end of the deal. The dollar seems to have stabilised, but at a level well below most estimates of its fundamental value. America likes this, of course, as a weak dollar boosts exports and encourages foreign investment, so helping the US climb out of its economic hole.

But until the currency strengthens further, Europe's acquiescence will be only partial, exposing the dollar to further speculative attack.

It's worth saying, also, that with oil hitting an incredible $124 a barrel last week, expensive crude will keep weighing down the trade balance of the world's biggest oil importer.

America external deficit remains the wrong side of $60bn - a figure that will escalate as long as oil stays dear. That reinforces the need for America to forego competitive benefits and allow the dollar to rise out of the danger zone to a level where its less prone to sudden collapse.

That level may not have yet been reached. I admit there are signs of flickering life in the US economy. Predictions of short-lived V-shaped recession could turn out to be true. But the upswing, if it comes, will be built on a combination of loose money and an unaffordable fiscal boost - hardly the platform for a solid recovery.

And, anyway, the biggest problem for the US isn't the eurozone: it's the rest of the world - in particular China, the other emerging giants and the Middle Eastern countries which peg their currencies to the dollar. The weak greenback is harming these countries as it forces them to import inflation. All the signs are that their patience is now wearing thin.

And, at the same time, these countries now call the shots, accounting for 75 per cent of the world's foreign currency reserves. So my prediction is that the US will soon reluctantly start talking the dollar up even more. But it won't be Brussels forcing them. It will be the likes of Riyadh and Beijing.

The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee made a good decision last Thursday, when it held rates at 5 per cent. It needs to make another good decision next month - and hold rates again - for the UK faces grave inflationary dangers.

The consumer slowdown and weak housing market are putting the MPC under massive pressure. Having cut rates last month, many interest groups - estate agents, stockbrokers and retailers - are screaming for the committee to go further. The MPC held last week only for "tactical" reasons, the rate-slashers say. The Bank avoided back-to-back cuts - a drastic measure last taken in response to 9/11 - for fear of causing panic. But I'd suggest this latest MPC decision was more "fundamental" - or, at least it should have been.

CPI inflation - at 2.5 per cent - is way above target. Shattering oil and food prices, along with a weak pound, mean it's about to get much worse. Inflation will soon breach 3 per cent - requiring the Bank to write a humiliating "explanatory" letter. And such are the price pressures in the system - one key wholesale inflation measure reads 18 per cent! - that more rate cuts would seriously damage the credibility of this country's monetary regime.

The spread between inter-bank and base rates is narrowing. The UK is a very long way from recession. That's why rates should be held for the foreseeable future - and the next move should be up.

Saying this will enrage various vested interests. But I'd rather be unpopular than wrong.

Last week saw the inauguration of Dmitri Medvedev - at 42, Russia's youngest head of state since the last Tsar, Nicholas II. Medvedev's ceremonials were quickly followed by the swearing-in of Vladimir Putin, his immediate predecessor, as prime minister. Kremlin watchers hope Medvedev - a technocratic lawyer - will usher in a "thaw" in East-West relations. They want the sometimes prickly Putin sidelined and can't grasp why he was such a popular president.

That's a question requiring no kremlinology whatsoever. Putin scored stellar domestic ratings because, over the last decade when he was in office, Russia has risen from nowhere to become the world's ninth largest economy. Income per head has grown ten-fold in dollar terms - with your average Russian now worth $12,012.

In 1999, Putin boasted that by 2015, Russians would be as rich as the Portuguese - Western Europe's poorest economy. Seeing as the average Russian income was then only 9 per cent of the average in Portugal, his claim was widely dismissed. But Russia has since grown so fast that average incomes are now 60 per cent of those in Portugal, and gaining fast. And if the two economies keep growing at the pace they have over the last decade, Russia's income per head will overtake Portugal's in 2014 - a year earlier than Putin's estimate.
Posted by:gorb

#10  Iran is the second largest importer of oil, crosspatch? Is that a typo, or am I missing something critical?

NPR did a big report on what used to be the subprime market crisis, and is now being called the credit crisis. A key point the reporter made is that the extent of investor losses is still not known, but definitely at least 50% of invested funds... the amount of which investments is still unclear. The other key point, to me, is that the investors are mostly formerly poor countries like China that have made so much profit off of sales to the U.S. that they had to park it somewhere, but U.S. Treasuries gave such a poor return that they looked toward AAA rated mortgage bonds for higher returns in what was purported to be nearly as safe an investment. Those countries are now back to chasing U.S. Treasuries, which should prove interesting. If I understand this correctly, China's currency has been de facto revalued, however slightly. Am I close?
Posted by: trailing wife   2008-05-11 23:16  

#9  We are just betting we can take more pressure for longer than Iran can apply it without bankrupting themselves.

At current prices, Iran's oil exports are about $110b a year, a little less than 1% of our annual domestic output.
Posted by: Zhang Fei   2008-05-11 22:15  

#8  In the past many oil producing countries took in dollars for their oil and invested those dollars, often here in the US.

What is now happening is that the second largest importer of oil (Iran) is unable to manage dollar denominated accounts because of US pressure on global banking. So ... they sell the dollars causing the price of dollars (value of the dollar) to go down and they buy other currencies such as the Euro causing the Euro to rise (even more than it already has from the dollar that was depressed by the initial selling). The result is a double-wammy on the dollar. We are betting that we can take it longer than Iran can since they nee d to purchase refined products which are valued in dollars on world markets. Every time they pressure the dollar, it makes their kerosene and food more expensive.

We are just betting we can take more pressure for longer than Iran can apply it without bankrupting themselves.
Posted by: crosspatch   2008-05-11 21:48  

#7  I will worry about the viability of the dollar on the day that the world's major drug cartels stop accepting it as standard payment.

I am soooo stealing that one.
Posted by: DarthVader   2008-05-11 21:09  

#6  I am convinced that we have been systematically driving the dollar down for some very strategic reasons. First of all, note how in the article it says several times that the US hasn't been punished in this deal.

To start with, the Chinese have been undervaluing their currency, the renminbi, and we warned them that it was going to cause a crisis. By slamming down the dollar, we are forcing them to revalue, which is also slowing down their economy.

In turn, their economy is a bubble economy, and if it slows, the bubble may burst. While this would cause a collapse in many world currencies, the US is insulated, because there would be a flight to quality, the USD.

Another reason is oil, several reasons right there. We are buying oil to protect ourselves in case there is a ME shutdown, but most of our purchases are a fixed contract prices, not the sky high spot market. This means as the dollar sinks, those low fixed prices are worth far less to OPEC.

The high speculation prices mean that they make their money off the spot market instead of from us.

Thus, if oil from the ME is cut off, the rest of the world will be in disaster, and the US will have at least two months reserve. This means two months of beating the snot out of the Iranians and restoring the flow.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2008-05-11 21:04  

#5  It appears that the herd is rampaging towards the proverbial cliff. Almost time to re-align the wagers in the ol' Forex account.
Posted by: AzCat   2008-05-11 20:59  

#4  By the way, I will worry about the viability of the dollar on the day that the world's major drug cartels stop accepting it as standard payment. Until then, the dollar is the world's medium of exchange with minor fluctuations attached to it.
Posted by: Shieldwolf   2008-05-11 19:19  

#3  So the Russians will be as wealth as Portugal in 2014, huh? That means that they will still be poorer than Slovenia. When the Russians catch up to the Italians, let me know; until then, they are simply trying to dig themselves out of the hole that 70 years of Soviet misrule dropped them in.
Posted by: Shieldwolf   2008-05-11 19:17  

#2  Rubbish. What are China and Russia going to say to Bernanke? Raise the value of the dollar or we'll drive it even lower?

In fact, the problem is going to be that the Fed has flooded the world with so many unwanted dollars that there is nothing they can do except grow our way out of the crisis or contract so much they precipitate depression. So there is little to be done about the situation except to show patience and consider who Bernanke's replacement will be by the next President. And remember what happened when Carter got to nominate a Fed chairman.

The other problem is that the world economy has changed so much that the central banks, even the Fed, can no longer control much. The IMF might have grown into an institution which could perform such functions, but it would be to far ahead of the political institutions and consensus needed to support it and in any case, it has become to powerless and despised.

Interesting times.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2008-05-11 17:42  

#1  Russia catches Portugal - the end of civilization as we now it!
Posted by: Harcourt Jush7795   2008-05-11 17:28  

00:00