You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Southeast Asia
US aid ships could soon leave Myanmar coast
2008-06-01
Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Sunday he will make a decision within "a matter of days" to withdraw U.S. Navy ships from the coast of Myanmar, because "it's becoming pretty clear the regime is not going to let us help."
As a result, he said many more people will die, particularly those in areas that can only be reached by helicopters, such as those sitting idle on the U.S. ships.

Asked if the military junta there is guilty of genocide, Gates said, "I tend to see genocide more as a purposeful elimination of people, this is more akin, in my view, to criminal neglect."

Speaking to reporters at the close of an international security conference here, Gates said the Myanmar representative at the forum did not seem interested in speaking with him. But, he said "it was interesting to watch as minister after minister described their respective unhappiness at their inability to get assistance in to Burma."

It was particularly pointed, he said, since Chinese officials thanked other countries for the help provided after the earthquake in China.

Still, Gates affirmed again that there is unanimous opposition in the international community to forcing aid to the Myanmar people suffering in the wake of the devastating cyclone that struck in early May. "There is great sensitivity all over the world to violating a country's sovereignty," Gates said. "Particularly in the absence of some kind of U.N. umbrella that would authorize it." Asked if that sensitivity is linked to the controversy surrounding the U.S. invasion of Iraq, Gates said he has heard no one make that connection.

Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said that even when the decision is made to pull the four U.S. Navy ships off the coast, the vessels will move away slowly enough to turn back if there is an unexpected change of heart by the Myanmar government.

Gates comments came a day after he made his strongest public condemnation of the Myanmar government at the conference, saying that Myanmar's rulers "have kept their hands in their pockets" while other countries sought to help cyclone victims. The widespread displeasure with the Myanmar government was clear at the conference, coming up in nearly all conversations among leaders.

Following the conference, Gates flew to Thailand on Sunday where large anti-government demonstrations threaten to lead to the country's second military coup in two years. Gates said he was not concerned about the potentially difficult situation and that canceling his visit could cause more of a problem than continuing on. He said he would urge officials in Bangkok to move to a democratically elected government.
Posted by:anonymous5089

#7  CHINESE MILITARY FORUM > US SECRETARY GATES WARNS CHINA NOT TO BULLY [Asian/Neighboring States] REGION ON ENERGY. BE TRANSPARENT - don't use the Chin PLA.

* SAME ARTICLE > GATES INDCS THAT US HAD TRIED 15 TIMES TO GET MYANMAR TO OPEN UP ON RELIEF BUT TO NO AVAIL???
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2008-06-01 20:33  

#6  Its good to see people who like there language to be unambiguous and clear

Sometimes you use a nuke, sometimes you use a knife.
Posted by: Pappy   2008-06-01 15:02  

#5  Its good to see people who like there language to be unambiguous and clear.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2008-06-01 12:15  

#4  Gates is getting a little Rummified.

Nah. It's verbal backhand - a 'don't attribute to evil genius what can be explained by garden-variety thuggery' comment.
Posted by: Pappy   2008-06-01 11:41  

#3  I seem to remember the Burmese leadership is really Chinese Army remnants from WWII. I doubt they have much in common or sympathy with the native Burmese.
Posted by: ed   2008-06-01 08:06  

#2  I tend to see genocide more as a purposeful elimination of people, this is more akin, in my view, to criminal neglect.

Gates is getting a little Rummified. Must be the ego trip of having the JCS report to you.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2008-06-01 07:59  

#1  A final decision still has not been made.

Ask anyone on the street corner in Peoria. You'll have your answer very quickly. Phuech Myanmar, bring em on home NOW!
Posted by: Besoeker   2008-06-01 07:19  

00:00