You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Britain
MoD moves captain in Iran captives affair
2008-07-29
A Royal Navy commander has been removed from his ship after 15 of his sailors and marines were captured by Iran last year. Cmdr Jeremy Woods, captain of the frigate HMS Cornwall, had been moved "to a post where his talents and experience can be used to best effect", the Ministry of Defence said. A spokesman denied the decision was connected to events in March last year, described at the time by the head of the navy as a "bad day" for the service.

Iranian revolutionary guards captured the seven Royal Marines and eight sailors at gunpoint after they left the Cornwall in a small vessel to search a ship in waters between Iran and Iraq. Iran - which insisted the group was in its waters, something the UK denied - held them for 13 days, before their release in a publicity exercise orchestrated by the Iranian president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

The navy's embarrassment was heightened by the way the crew appeared willing to be paraded before the world's media in Iranian-provided suits, shaking Ahmadinejad's hand and smiling. Further criticism followed when two of the captives, Faye Turney and Arthur Batchelor, were allowed to sell their stories to the media. The latter was particularly castigated for complaining that his iPod had been taken. In December the Commons defence committee called the affair a "national embarrassment" and recommended formal disciplinary action against those responsible.

Woods is a navy veteran of 23 years who took command of HMS Cornwall in late 2006 after captaining a minesweeper, HMS Bangor. "This is an internal administrative matter between the individual and his senior officers and we will not give further details," a spokesman said.

The capture of the boarding party was described by Admiral Sir Jonathon Band, the first sea lord, as "one bad day in our proud 400-year history".

An internal MoD inquiry blamed bad intelligence, inadequate training, confused communications and poor judgment by senior commanders. The defence secretary, Des Browne, did not make public the inquiry's findings.
Posted by:Steve White

#10  That's about 9 USN COs this year.
Posted by: Pappy   2008-07-29 23:55  

#9  NOT A GOOD DAY FOR US CAPTAINS EITHER!

FREEREPUBLIC > USN Capt Valverde reportedly relieved after his "GATOR NAVY" amphib auxil ship USS PEARL HARBOR hit a sandbar and got stuck ???
Poster - Other Ship Officers stand to have damaged careers after this incident - might as well start prepping their civilian resumes as per lost future USN promotions.
Posted by: JosephMendiola   2008-07-29 21:07  

#8  Sounds about like the Falklands. Hope he's learned a lesson, and is brushing up on his Spanish.
Posted by: Glenmore   2008-07-29 19:34  

#7  
had been moved "to a post where his talents and experience can be used to best effect",


That used to mean counting things in a lonely warehouse on a little used base far, far away.
Posted by: Steve   2008-07-29 18:36  

#6  So what are the ROE now and what were they?!
Posted by: Bulldog   2008-07-29 12:58  

#5  Rum, sodomy and the lash.
Posted by: mojo   2008-07-29 11:32  

#4  Nice touch with the pic of the olde admiral thar Doc.
Posted by: .5MT   2008-07-29 09:47  

#3  That's Britain for you these days. Better a national embarassment than an international incident.
Posted by: gromky   2008-07-29 06:54  

#2  If I recall correctly, Cmdr Woods called home to the Ministry of Defence to ask for guidance on how to handle the situation, and was told to let the crew be captured rather than create an international incident.
Posted by: trailing wife    2008-07-29 06:24  

#1  Bloody embarrassing affair .
Posted by: Mad Eye   2008-07-29 04:39  

00:00