| Submit your comments on this article |
| India-Pakistan |
| Psychotic terrorists in search of a grievance |
| 2008-12-03 |
| By David Aaronovitch So, why kill the rabbi? There is a branch of apologetics - which I take crudely to be the belief that the crime is the fault of the victim - that assumes a milder form, and which I'll call explanetics. So the explanatists view of the Mumbai massacres last week is that the cause lies in what concretely has been done to, or in the vicinity of, the young, cool-looking men with the grenades and the machineguns. On the day after the attacks began the Indian writer, campaigner and serial explanatist, Arundhati Roy, lambasted her own country on The World Tonight on Radio 4, for its rural poverty and its fluctuating support for Hindu nationalism. These, she seemed to suggest, were root causes of the terror. Elsewhere, analysts have pointed to the 60-year-old Kashmiri crisis as fuelling the jihad. More exotically the writer Misha Glenny now suggests that organised crime in the Pakistani city of Karachi is "the operational key" to such attacks (he has just written a book about international organised crime), but that the origins of last week's nightmare lie "in the deterioration in relations between Hindus and Muslims in Mumbai and India". Well, these things are bad. Kashmir is bad. Hindu communalism is bad. Poverty is bad. You can see the reasons for warfare in Kashmir, for riots in Hyderabad and for Maoist uprisings in the deep rural areas of India. But why kill the rabbi? Why invade the small headquarters of a small outreach sect of a small religion, which far from being even a big symbol of anything, you would almost certainly need a detailed map and inside knowledge even to find? From what has been learnt from the one surviving attacker, the baby-faced and variously pre-named Mr Kasab, his group came largely from the rural southern Punjab in Pakistan. It is therefore unlikely that any of them had even encountered a Jew, or knew anyone else who had. Yet last week, Nariman House was chosen for special murderous attention, alongside the Oberoi and Taj hotels, the railway station and the Leopold café. It reminded me of the 2003 Istanbul bombings when - post Iraq war - specifically British and American targets were augmented, for some reason, by the blowing up of the synagogues belonging to the much diminished Jewish population of that great city. |
| Posted by:john frum |
| #4 Michael Toten had some interesting observations of AQI prisoners he visited in Fallujah: These guys are like Arabic Hannibal Lectors. “Is it safe to be in here?” I said. “Well,” Sergeant Dehaan said. “There’s five cops. And me.” Most of the men in this room looked like they were perfectly willing to murder us all with their hands. I could see it in their eyes, in the sinister way some of them squinted at me, in the tightness of their jaw muscles. I wished I had a gun of my own. “The nastiest ones are the little guys,” Sergeant Dehaan said. “The little rat-looking bastards. They're the ones who have done the worst things to people.” I’ve seen how cruel Iraqi kids can be when they fight over candy the Marines hand out to them. The little rat-looking insurgents most likely were mercilessly picked on as children. When they joined Al Qaeda their bottomless hatred was unleashed against Iraqis even more than it was unleashed on the Americans. Another interesting study was published by the DOD. It looked at Islamic suicide bombers, and discovered that they were largely 4th, 5th or 6th sons in a family. When you look at the high unemployment and stagnant economies in Arab countries, most of the jobs, inheritance etc. is going to go to the first or second sons. Becoming a suicide bomber can be seen as a desperate attempt to get some positive aclaim from the family and the community. I believe that Islamo-terrorists are murderers first and Muslims second. |
| Posted by: Frozen Al 2008-12-03 15:57 |
| #3 Drop the big one ........................... |
| Posted by: Last Breath Farm Resident 2008-12-03 08:45 |
| #2 And their oil-tick masters whom successive US presidents (of both parties) are happy to call friends & allies. |
| Posted by: g(r)omgoru 2008-12-03 05:39 |
| #1 IIRC, the Rabbi's wife = better half has reportedly been discovered to be a few or five months preggers at her time of death in Mumbai??? |
| Posted by: JosephMendiola 2008-12-03 02:09 |