You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Land of the Free
We should get rid of local policing. Ferguson shows why the system just doesn't work
2014-11-30
[WAPO] BLUF: Centralizing law enforcement also will improve oversight and reduce corruption. In the current system, corrupt cops and police chiefs often enjoy long tenures, sheltered in autonomous local departments. A statewide system offers more accountability. While concerns about misconduct or corruption are being investigated, accused officers -- or entire divisions -- could be moved to another part of the state to ease tensions in the local community and reduce opportunities for biased treatment in their home jurisdictions.
[Pirate's Cove:] "It's interesting how virtually every policy from Progressives means more and more power in the hands of more centralized government, eh? They love the idea of moving everything away from the local level, where government can be more responsive, be held accountable to a better degree, where people know their government officials. This is a Progressive's wet dream. Except when it negatively impacts themselves, then they are upset.

And, of course, in Progressive World, higher level officials never ever can be unprofessional and inefficient."
Posted by:

#22  The biggest problem with an Obama national police force is that most Americans cannot speak Spanish.
Posted by: Ebbomosh Hupemp2664   2014-11-30 22:30  

#21  The system we have now starts with local police. In Maryland we have city/township police, county police, and state police. Pennsylvania has township/borough police and state police. Both state police organizations are very straight, very no-nonsense. County police vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but recruitment is local for the most part, meaning you get local knowledge.

The writer has seemingly never had a look at countries with centralized police operations.

Moving "entire divisions" from jurisdiction to jurisdiction on the assumption they're interchangeable parts is a recipe for disaster.
Posted by: Fred   2014-11-30 21:30  

#20  I am sure they will just as non-partial, fair and honest as the IRS. Right.
Posted by: Ebbomosh Hupemp2664   2014-11-30 21:01  

#19  It is already in place. DHS has a police force. They come to the community and augment when necessary, such as in Ferguson. Next step is for them to declare the ferg police to be so corrupt they need to start over. DHS steps in, fed funding to the state stops, then DHS never leaves.
Posted by: 49 Pan   2014-11-30 20:37  

#18  SD County Sheriffs Kolendar (for about 110 yrs) and Ex-FBI guy Gore have continued the fight against "shall carry". Of course, campaign donors and "honorary sheriffs" had no qualms. F*CK them. THIS is why we need national constitutional protections
Posted by: Frank G   2014-11-30 18:45  

#17  I was curious about the author both having a PhD and being a 17 year vet with the LAPD. Couldn't find the PhD subject, but he is/was teaching homeland security at Colorado Tech. He is also noted as the author of a piece stating (tl;dr) "don't f**k with cops, we'll kick your ass". (yeah, I'm paraphrasing)

Perhaps instead of creating a StadtPolitzei, we could instead create de jure bantustans instead of the de facto ones we have now. It all depends on the actual problem we are trying to solve.
Posted by: SteveS   2014-11-30 16:02  

#16  I sense a potential secret benefactor.

Sadly, I sense a deal - "DOJ can't prove anything but we can still make your life a living hell. Get out of town and we won't push it."

Mike
Posted by: Mike Kozlowski   2014-11-30 15:42  

#15  The USSR was the exemplar of centralised accountability and lack of corruption lol.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2014-11-30 15:41  

#14  Officer Wilson has resigned, reportedly with no pension or severance pay. I sense a potential secret benefactor.

Michael Anthony (Marvin Miller) hands check to Betty Perkins (Inger Stevens) in a 1956 episode of the Millionaire.


Posted by: Besoeker   2014-11-30 13:38  

#13  ^^If he had, he would've spilled the location so the lynch mob could do "Justice"
Posted by: Frank G   2014-11-30 13:26  

#12  Just curious... When Holder visited - did he ever visit Officer Wilson?
Posted by: CrazyFool   2014-11-30 12:53  

#11  Ferguson an excuse for expanding the powers of Homeland Security - "This is my last election ... After my election I have more flexibility,"
Posted by: Blinky Glosing9128   2014-11-30 12:41  

#10  Hey no problem. I nominate Joe as national police czar.
Posted by: Besoeker   2014-11-30 12:23  

#9  The administration just floated a Trial Balloon via WAPO...

Posted by: Blinky Glosing9128   2014-11-30 12:21  

#8  If anything, the Police force should be More localized.

In Hong Kong, you may elect members of Parliament and your Prime Minister, but all state and local positions will be filled by appointees from Beijing.

Machine over man.
Posted by: newc   2014-11-30 12:21  

#7  You don't use locals to keep locals in charge...because they are locals. Straight tyrant agit-prop.

What is this, is a suggestion for the college tuition program sponsored by the Department of Homeland Security and Health Human Services.

Citizen! Put in your 2 years of public service Today! Six month rotations run counter-clockwise to the college bowl series - make new friends, spread your team colors, get fit!

Citizen Service means Citizen Tax Breaks, Free Tuition, and Bonus Tacos on Tuesday! Forward!
Posted by: swksvolFF   2014-11-30 11:32  

#6  The Reichstag Fire. Take an event, feed the hysteria (with your agents), then declare the need for more Power(tm).
Posted by: Procopius2k   2014-11-30 09:32  

#5  And when the centralized police chief decides to ignore the law we get illegal immigration, IRS and EPA abuse. Yeah let us implement that at every level. Layers of law enforcement is suppose to keep a watch on the different levels.
Posted by: Airandee   2014-11-30 09:15  

#4  The opposite is true. If there wasn't a federal involvement - in the form of Obama and Holder. Or the racist twins (Jackson, Sharpton) and their bus loads of 'Community Organizers' aka Thugs. Or the lawyer flying in from elsewhere to stir the pot (and the parents being stupid enough to think he represents them) the riots wouldn't have happened.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2014-11-30 08:57  

#3  Yay, lets bring in the Stasi to those black areas because black cannot govern and police themselves. Progressive's racism is showing.

Posted by: OldSpook   2014-11-30 08:47  

#2  Are they gonna name the new state police Gestapo?
Posted by: chris   2014-11-30 08:07  

#1  Perhaps a new paradigm. Blacks wont become cops but they do sign on to be security guards. Perhaps privitize and have private security patrols instead.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2014-11-30 07:43  

00:00