You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
India-Pakistan
16/12/14: Never forget
2014-12-17
[DAWN] As condemnations from politicians began to roll out (like paper does from a photocopying machine), one immediately felt that in spite of such automated and cyclostyled exhibitions of grief that usually emerge in times of a national tragedy in Pakistain, the country's most recent collision with terror was drawing a somewhat different reaction.
It's always a different reaction with every new atrocity--approximately every ten days.
This time, outrage from the usual quarters (that are unfortunately mocked for being overtly 'sensationalist') was not quite coupled by the reptilian waffle and reactionary drivel that often emerges alongside the ire.
Give it time.
On social media sites such as Twitter and Facebook, one actually felt a profound sense of shock even in some of the most animated sections, which, on normal days take the lead in immediately spinning up theories and narratives that obfuscate a tragedy ‐ any tragedy, even including the slaughter of men and women by the self-claimed warriors of faith.
They trade ideas on how to be atrocious. Boko Haram did something similar not thirty days ago.
But this sense of shock in such people was largely exhibited by a long, awkward silence. After all, many of them had been wagging their fingers at all and sundry for bringing upon Pakistain so much violence and bloodshed; blaming everyone from 'US imperialism' to 'liberal fascists' to drone attacks, to 'sold-out media houses' to even a group of teenage girls who were shot by bandidos murderous Moslems in Swat
...a valley and an administrative district in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province of Pakistain, located 99 mi from Islamabad. It is inhabited mostly by Pashto speakers. The place has gone steadily downhill since the days when Babe Ruth was the Sultan of Swat...
three years ago ‐ yes, everyone but those who, by and large, are actually committing the violence.


Zaid Hamid Syed Zaiduzzaman Hamid, better known as Zaid Hamid, is a Pakistani security consultant and political commentator.


Nevertheless, many of them were caught in no man's land when school children began to fall by the dozens to the bullets and bombs of bandidos murderous Moslems at a school in Beautiful Downtown Peshawar.
...capital of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (formerly known as the North-West Frontier Province), administrative and economic hub for the Federally Administered Tribal Areas of Pakistan. Peshawar is situated near the eastern end of the Khyber Pass, convenient to the Pak-Afghan border. Peshawar has evolved into one of Pakistan's most ethnically and linguistically diverse cities, which means lots of gunfire.
Just how could one justify, rationalise and obfuscate the mindless slaughter of school children and that too for an obscure, myopic and vindictive cause?
Who was the holy man who issued the fatwa saying it was okay under Islam to slit the throats of little kids? Guy who used to live in Britain? Religious authority for Algeria's GAI?
One just couldn't, and thus the silence.
One doesn't have to. Islam = Sadism.
One could easily taunt those who went suddenly quiet on that dreadful day. But the truth is that despite their penchant for tweeting and 'facebooking' arrogant spiels and convoluted rationales for reactionary shenanigans, their silence did prove that their minds were still mammalian in nature and hadn't entirely regressed to becoming reptilian.
The "peace" Islam brings is the peace of the grave.
One did see a few statements being quoted here and there about that ubiquitous (but always elusive) 'foreign hand', but such statements were overwhelmed by the anger and the grief that erupted across the country.
Short attention span syndrome is just around the corner.
It is correct to point out that politicising a tragedy of such a magnitude would be trivialising it. Yes, there are still mainstream political parties out there who remain frustratingly obscure and vague about their stand on the issue of terrorism and extremism in Pakistain.
As long as you've got religious parties you're ruled by holy men. As long as you've got blasphemy law you're ruled by holy men. The faithful turn out to riot a the least hint of blasphemy, but we never see them stringing up the nearest Taliban.
Yes, one of them just couldn't get itself to make a decision (about challenging this issue head-on) and was pushed into making one by the military; and yes, another party just refused to see beyond the nose of its rather contrived and naïve understanding of the same issue.
It's not only in Pakistain that tight turban doublethink is regarded as "naive," but it's ground zero.
Never mind the fact that I once saw two very popular rock stars (in a news report) actually suggesting that 'extremism was not an issue in Pakistain.'
Suffocation isn't an issue in a vacuum.
Never mind the fact that the proof is in the pudding and both the gentlemen kept repeating their brilliant insight even when the pudding was flowing from their mouths, nose and ears.

Never mind the apologists who only a few months ago (on TV) were describing civilian deaths in terror attacks as ' casualties of war', but then in the same breath insisted 'this is not our war.'

Yes, all this is true, but despite the cynical fear that this tragedy might soon be forgotten, I have never before seen so many distinct Paks behaving as if each one of them was now on the same boat.

The entirely meaningless and horrid deaths of all those school kids have well and truly shocked the nation like no other tragedy or act of terror. In each one of those fallen boys and girls, Paks across classes, ethnicities and political inclinations saw a child of their own ‐ a son, a daughter, a nephew, a grandchild ... It is unfortunate that a nation who considers itself to be proud, patriotic and passionate, had to wait right till the point where their children began to fall so tragically, so heartbreakingly to finally come to a state of a sombre and desperate unity.

This must not be forgotten. This must never be forgotten. This must be molded in the making of a brand new existential narrative for the besieged nation.

This point of unity achieved with the senseless deaths of over 50,000 Pak civilians, soldiers, politicians, cops and now over a hundred school children must be free of all politics and ideologies punctuated by false bravado, obfuscation, paranoid theories or cyclic navel-gazing.

Our military leaders, civilian representatives in the parliament (and even on the streets), our media, in fact each one of us must immediately strive to reach that long-awaited new consensus about exactly what kind of a Pakistain we want; how to achieve it and, more so, make sure that never again will we allow a madness that causes thousands of mothers and fathers cry over the still bodies of their children.
Posted by:Fred

#4  That reference to India and December 16th in the Tweet is because December 16th is Victory Day in India.

From Wikipedia:

"Victory Day) is also commemorated every 16 December in India as it marks its military victory over Pakistan in 1971 during the Indo-Pakistani War of 1971, who were alliance of Bangladesh Mukti Bahini . The end of the war also resulted in the unilateral and unconditional surrender of the Pakistan Army and subsequent secession of East Pakistan into Bangladesh. On this day in 1971, the chief of the Pakistani forces, General Amir Abdullah Khan Niazi, along with 93,000 troops, surrendered to the allied forces consists of Indian Army and Mukti Bahini, led by General Jagjit Singh Aurora, of India in the Ramna Race Course, now Suhrawardy Udyan, in Dhaka after their defeat in the war.[1] The anniversary of Vijay Divas is observed across India by paying tributes to the martyrs who laid down their lives for the nation. In the nation's capital New Delhi, the Indian Minister of Defence and heads of all three wings of the Indian armed forces pay homage at Amar Jawan Jyoti at India Gate in New Delhi as well as in the National Military Memorial, Bangalore.[citation needed]

On December 16 every year, Citizens, senior officials, students & war veterans lay wreaths and remember the sacrifices of the soldiers. Member of Parliament Mr. Rajeev Chandrasekhar, who has continued to support the ex servicemen and the armed forces and pursued One Rank One Pension, says, "Don't let down our heroes, as we commemorate Vijay Diwas."
Posted by: DLR   2014-12-17 20:36  

#3  Tehreek-i-Taliban said they did it because Malala got the Nobel Prize. *shrug* It's as good an excuse as any for hitting out at the army for killing their people. It's not like they can do anything against the American drones, after all.
Posted by: trailing wife   2014-12-17 18:18  

#2  Kill the brood of the Army, spread fear and influence, try to outsplash ISJV.

Though I'm sure the official tagline was a movie badmouthing mo and featuring a polytheist two headed dog. And you, its your fault, or something.

I believe the last 12 months have provided ample evidence on the ROEs. I have drawn my conclusions.
Posted by: swksvolFF   2014-12-17 15:11  

#1  Has anyone claimed credit or provided a realistic explanation of why yet?
Posted by: rjschwarz   2014-12-17 14:41  

00:00