You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Britain
The Alfie Evans story - Is Great Britain Still a Free Country?
2018-04-28
[Townhall] Even as a steadfast critic of the UK's socialistic healthcare system, I'll happily admit to being a full-blown Anglophile. I adore our beloved cousins and close allies across the pond. I enjoy visiting the United Kingdom, from London to Birmingham to Edinburgh. I believe the "special relationship" between our two countries is a cornerstone of global security. I'm an avid consumer of British television shows, from the Bake Off to Broadchurch. And above all, I love the warm, clever, welcoming British people. Even their food has improved. So it genuinely pains me to be pondering this question over the last few days: Is Britain still a free country that values Western democratic values? Chief among those core principles are the protection of innocent human life, freedom of speech, freedom of expression, and free citizens' ability to go about their daily lives without undue or heavy-handed interference from government. While the Brits remain -- and should remain -- our close friends, and while our national interests still align in many ways, I cannot help but look on with sadness and occasional revulsion as the British State increasingly seems to regard and treat its citizens as subjects.

The people of the UK are still able to elect their leaders and impose dramatic changes, of course, so it would be a gross overstatement to liken their government (as some critics have) to a totalitarian regime. But a string of recent stories and incidents have raised serious fears in my mind about whether Great Britain is becoming something other than -- something less than -- a truly free country. I'll lay out a number of examples, and allow readers draw their own conclusions regarding that provocative proposition, starting with: (1) The appalling and inhumane treatment of Alfie Evans and his family.

Many Americans may recall the Charlie Gard case from 2017, wherein the parents of an ailing young boy were ordered by the government not to travel to the US to explore groundbreaking treatment for their son's extremely serious condition. After a protracted legal battle, the state prevailed. Young Charlie Gard was not permitted to leave Britain, care was ceased, and he died. A similar, grotesque saga featuring another terminally ill baby is playing out today:
Posted by:Besoeker

#13  We rely on UK media for real news. The only good thing about an otherwise socialist, soon to be sharia island, to offset a socialist US media of a soon to be a socialist plantation nation.
Posted by: Omeger Gray6606   2018-04-28 18:50  

#12  1) their food was fine. To the extent they imported exotic flavors, they didn't need to import exotic populations and exotic diseases, too.

2) Of course they're not free. They can't get medical care without their masters' approval, they're not permitted to defend themselves, and they're not allowed to speak a single negative word about Islam.

3) They could be free again. Even with the monarchy -- there was a time when Britons were EXPECTED to be able to defend themselves, could get any medical care they could find, and could even criticize other religions. They just have to throw out the government that puts pedophiles in charge of watching over the well-being of abused children...

Posted by: Rob Crawford   2018-04-28 18:29  

#11  They knew their son would die but by intervening maybe the next kid would get 3 months.

It depends on whether one’s goal is to advance scientific knowledge in order to more effectively treat patients in the future, or to reduce the already overwhelming burden on the entirety of the medical health care system.
Posted by: trailing wife   2018-04-28 16:07  

#10  No, they are not a free country. Haven't been in decades now. The UK has pretty much always been a police state, abet a polite and often ironic one. They are not, and have never been, a political model that should be emulated. (Note: I too am an Anglophile. Anglican educated, and member of the Anglican Communion. Love the people and their culture, despise their government.)
Posted by: Secret Master   2018-04-28 15:50  

#9  Scumbag move by a third world shithole. Ironic that we saved them from the Nazis only to have them become Nazis.
Posted by: Regular joe   2018-04-28 15:28  

#8  I would say this was one of Sarah Palin's death panels at work, but it's really more like a firing squad. And hat's off to the head of the Church of England, you chickenshit heathen.
Posted by: Matt   2018-04-28 13:42  

#7  Just a terrible decision for humanity but logical for socialism.

Years ago a friend had a son with a life ending heart defect. They were giving the option of letting their son die with no intervention or try and get a few weeks of life. They knew their son would die but by intervening maybe the next kid would get 3 months. Let the parents decide.
Posted by: Airandee    2018-04-28 13:20  

#6  Death penalty only for embarrassing the state and it's apparatchiks.
Posted by: Bright Pebbles   2018-04-28 13:00  

#5  We have our own. They also wear robes.
Rantburg rimshot of the day award winner.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2018-04-28 08:29  

#4  Take a global look around. Nothing more 'Deep State' than a monarchy.
Posted by: Besoeker   2018-04-28 08:06  

#3  They are 'subjects'. Americans are citizens. There's a reason some gentlemen, who just a short time before were British subjects, wrote something referred to as the Bill of Rights.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2018-04-28 08:02  

#2  Even their food has improved.

Because that's the yardstick to measure how awesome a country is.
Posted by: Raj   2018-04-28 07:00  

#1  Alfie has died, once again proving how gloriously the NHS in England can kill small children. Since he was able to breathe without machines, they used the tried and true liverpool pathway and denied food and water.

I guess it's too much to hope for that the judges involved get hacked to death by jihadi's for denying the parents the ability to seek alternative care.

I have a kid and these things hit pretty hard. Plus, being descended from Appalachian mountain folk tends to make me...well, few people hold a grudge the way we do.

Posted by: Silentbrick   2018-04-28 03:55  

00:00