You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Politix
Gov. Cuomo Falsely Blames Trump for New York's $2.3 Billion Budget Shortfall
2019-02-07
[Breitbart] Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D-NY) is blaming President Trump for his state’s $2.3 billion budget shortfall.

According to Cuomo, it was Trump’s tax cut that caused "many of the state’s richest residents ‐ who pay 46 percent of the state’s income tax ‐ to either change their primary residence or leave New York entirely."

Let me back up a bit...

What Trump’s tax reform did was to restore fairness to the tax code, was to put an end to the injustice of all Americans ‐ including those in the middle class ‐ paying for the sky high tax rates in states like New York.

You see, before Trump reformed the tax code, all Americans were subsidizing the rich.

It used to be that you could write off every penny of your state income tax on your federal income tax. Trump put an end to this outrage. Here’s how it works...

In the state of New York, if you earn over $1.078 million per year, you pay an income tax to the state of almost nine percent.

In other words, using round numbers, a New York resident who earns $10 million owes the state of New York close to $900,000 in income taxes. But...

Democrat-run states like New York knew that their rich residents would not feel the sting of that $900,000 tax bill because that $900,000 could be written off of their federal tax bill.

Basically, this was a sleazy way for Blue States to steal money from federal taxpayers, to make all of us pay for their grotesque tax rates. These Democrat-run states not only got all of this tax money, they also avoided getting voted out of office for over-taxing because the federal write-off removed most of the sting for the wealthy taxpayer.
Posted by:Besoeker

#14  Here I thought Emmanuel Goldstein was to blame.
Posted by: regular joe   2019-02-07 13:26  

#13  But then, in the 1970s, the people who were leaving New York were not rich. They just didn't like living in a hell hole. If the very rich Manhattan and Hamptons types are moving into your state it might be a good thing.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2019-02-07 13:03  

#12  Back in the 1970s it seem every other car in southern California had New York or New Jersey plates. A lot of them had Texas plates. Not my fault if some of those loose fruits and nuts who rolled into California are now rolling out.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2019-02-07 12:59  

#11  The way I understand it certain states like NY and California have been taking advantage of the Federal tax code allowing one to take high state taxes as a deduction. Trump closed that idiocy so now the high taxes in those states are very, very, obvious to even the dimmest folks.

So he's probably right to some extent, although it's like blaming the guy who turned on the lights for everyone seeing the room is messy.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2019-02-07 10:18  

#10  We should wall NYC off, dump the population of California in it and install cameras every where. Last one alive gets to leave. Oh and everyone will be issued with either a rock, tennis ball, eraser or other democrat approved way to 'fight' an active shooter.
Posted by: Silentbrick   2019-02-07 10:03  

#9  ny is run by morally bancrupt beasts.
Posted by: Ebbavirt Clunk4147   2019-02-07 09:56  

#8  I call it the "Locust Effect".

A biblical metaphor. I like it!
Posted by: Besoeker   2019-02-07 09:06  

#7  Unfortunately, the people fleeing vote for the same things that made where they came from a shithole.

I call it the "Locust Effect". They move from place to place destroying it so they can't stay and with no understanding of what they did to destroy it.
Posted by: DarthVader   2019-02-07 09:02  

#6  Make them feel welcome by slashing their tires.
Posted by: Jim Cramer6666666   2019-02-07 08:59  

#5  Registered and voting in both
Posted by: Frank G   2019-02-07 08:56  

#4  I'm sure they are already registered in the state as Demonrat voters. Along with all their dead relatives.
Posted by: Silentbrick   2019-02-07 07:36  

#3  First thing they do on arrival is register as D voters?
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2019-02-07 03:05  

#2  ....far more likely the drop in tax revenue is due to people leaving the state. This will come out in the following days.

Here in Georgia you can see them arriving daily. NY car tags, NJ tags, California tags.
Posted by: Besoeker   2019-02-07 01:57  

#1  The other reason this is pure bullshit - think of a state tax return that allows for Federal itemized deductions, as the NY state income tax return does. When you eliminate those deductions, your taxable income becomes higher, does it not? Cuomo tries to describe a situation that does not exist; far more likely the drop in tax revenue is due to people leaving the state. This will come out in the following days.
Posted by: Raj   2019-02-07 01:10  

00:00