You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Arabia
Why is civic honesty lacking in Arab, Islamic countries?
2019-06-26
[ENGLISH.ALARABIYA.NET] Late June saw the leading scientific journal, Science, publish an article ranking a sample of 40 countries in civic honesty, where people voluntarily refrain from opportunistic behavior. Worryingly for Arab and Islamic countries, they dominated the lowest positions in the rankings, while the highest positions were reserved for the countries with the highest living standards. While it is difficult to demonstrate a definitive causal relationship between civic honesty and economic success, the data should make policymakers think hard about the need to make people trust each other more as part of their economic strategies.

The authors of the paper, titled "Civil honesty across the globe," conducted an experiment whereby a covert associate would return a "lost" wallet to one of five societal institutions (a bank, theater/museum, post office, hotel, or cop shoppe). The wallet would contain the contact details of the fictitious owner- an email address was created by the researchers- as well as some money and some personal possessions. The associate would say that they were in a hurry, and ask the receiving staff to assist in returning the wallet to its rightful owner. They did this with 17,000 wallets across 40 countries, allowing them to create a ranking of the 40 countries in terms of the likelihood that the lost wallet be returned.

Students of economics should be unsurprised by the top five countries: Switzerland
Posted by:Fred

#6  You may be dubious about the hbd interpretations, but hbdchick had some interesting maps of different cultural features across Europe and the Middle East.

IIRC her hypothesis was that close cousin marriages bred attitudes of stronger family ties and weaker ties to the wider society.
Posted by: james   2019-06-26 21:52  

#5  where people voluntarily refrain from opportunistic behavior

Why would a normative concept inherent in one culture be anticipated in another?
Posted by: Skidmark   2019-06-26 12:23  

#4  the US and UK didn't do very well either

Well anyone who isn't Nordic (there's that Lutheran thingy several hundred years ago). Even they are starting to fail as well in dealing with the consequence of the influx of Islamists into their lands. What problem?
Posted by: Procopius2k   2019-06-26 08:37  

#3  As I've said before, malanthropy is intrinsic in the Arab male. Generations of harsh survival in an environment of feud, communal enmities, coups and bloodshed. The religion of islam was created only to justify these traits and weaponize them. It contains an institutionalized ideology of hatred, deception, crime, plodding gradually toward conquest. It is the ultimate Asshole Manual.

The lack of civic honesty in many countries could be simply due to economic reasons (like India). Also honesty of citizens is often directly proportional to the honesty of the governments themselves. But in islamic nations, no amount of progress or transparency has been able to reform the average delinquent muslim.
Posted by: Dron66046   2019-06-26 07:20  

#2  Why is civic honesty lacking in Arab, Islamic countries?

Islam. Asked, Answered.
Posted by: Woodrow   2019-06-26 05:14  

#1  the US and UK didn't do very well either

original article in "Science mag" is here

and below

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2019/06/19/science.aau8712?utm_campaign=fr_sci_2019-06-20&et_rid=33778125&et_cid=2868769
Posted by: lord garth   2019-06-26 01:03  

00:00