You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Signs, Portents, and the Weather-
Colorado State: Don’t Use the Word ‘America’ Because It’s Not ‘Inclusive’
2019-07-25
[NATIONALREVIEW] Colorado State University’s Inclusive Language Guide instructs students "to avoid" using the words "America" and "American," because doing so "erases other cultures."
Better to call ourselves Unitedstatesians or perhaps merely Imperialists.
"The Americas encompass a lot more than the United States," the guide states. "There is South America, Central America, Mexico, Canada, and the Caribbean just to name a few of 42 countries in total."
I blame it on de Tocqueville. "Democracy in America" didn't address the striving masses of Peru.
"That’s why the word ’americano’ in Spanish can refer to anything on the American continent. Yet, when we talk about ’Americans’ in the United States, we’re usually just referring to people from the United States. This erases other cultures and depicts the United States as the dominant American country."
Where do we Unitedstatesians get off referring to Canadians, and Mexicans, and Guatamalans?
The guide advises students to use the words "U.S. citizen" or "person from the U.S." instead of "American."
And they shouldn't use the word "Coloradan," either. What if somebody's from Wyoming? From Utah? If he's from Manitoba his/her/its head will explode.
Some of the other words and phrases deemed not inclusive by the guide include the words "male" and "female" (because this "refers to biological sex and not gender," and "we very rarely need to identify or know a person’s biological sex and more often are referring to gender"),
"Gender" relies on dress, hair, and self-identification, rather than on characteristics of the pee-pee, which is considered irrelevant, whether on display or not, as it is with distressing frequency...
"cake walk" (because it apparently has origins in "the racism of 19th century minstrel shows"),
It was a silly dance, performed internationally by whites as well. If black people ever discover the Chicken Dance nobody in Europe will ever be able to get married again. You should also be careful about using a jig saw or having a fling. Never, ever, under any circumstances, eat Eskimo Pie.
"freshman" (because it "excludes women and non-binary gender identities"),
Use "fresh people."
"Hispanic" ("because of its origins in colonialization and the implication that to be Hispanic or Latinx/Latine/Latino, one needs to be Spanish-speaking"),
Yet somehow they're always brown. Go figure. And no goddamned sombreros! Ever!
"hold down the fort" (because "the U.S. the historical connotation refers to guarding against Native American ’intruders’ and feeds into the stereotype of ’savages’"),
No fort, you know, ever actually needed held down against Apaches or Commanches or Sioux, not even against Croatans or Mingos or Powhattans. Nope. Never. Bernard Cornwell wrote a novel called The Fort in which the Brits were holding the fort (pardon my English!) against the Americans Unitedstatesians Colonists, including Paul Revere. Yeah, that one. Hardly a man/woman/non-binary is still alive, who remembers that night in '75... Actually none of them.
"no can do" (because it was "[o]riginally a way to mock Chinese people"),
"So long" is forbidden, too. It comes from Malay "Salang," which is the local form of "Salaam," which is cognate with "Shalom," which is Hebrew, thus Zionist. I heard "no can do" lots of times in Vietnam. Sometimes I still say "ching ching" when something is true; I got that in Thailand. And I occasionally even say "same-o same-o (onaji desu)" in the same context younger folk use "same-old same-old." But I'm a polyglot, so my poor old head's swimming with interesting phrasing.
"peanut gallery" (because it "names a section in theaters, usually the cheapest and worst, where many Black people sat during the era of Vaudeville”),
Vaudeville? How about the kiddie gallery on the Howdy Doody Show?
“straight” (because it “implies that anyone LGBT is ‘crooked’ or not normal”),
Or if you're military, it means that your pants are creased, your bunk made, your gig line straight, and your brass polished. How militaristic.
“food coma” (because it “directly alludes to the stereotype of laziness associated with African-Americans”),
Never heard the term. Sounds like an overdose of carbohydrates, doesn't it?
and “war” or “battle,” when used any way other than to describe a literal war or battle (because “they evoke very real tragedy that can be problematic for survivors of war or Veterans”).
For instance a War on Language? Thought shapes action. Language shapes thought.
Posted by:Fred

#12  Never, ever, under any circumstances, eat Eskimo Pie.

Translation of Inuit ballad:
"If ancestral wisdom be valid,
It seems that the tarts
Of more southerly parts
Are surpassingly torrid, not gelid!"
Posted by: Titus Peacock7962   2019-07-25 20:19  

#11  Don't call it Colorado, a name given to it by the evil white Spanish invaders explorers. All Western Civ BAD! (do I need to put a /sarc on that?)
Posted by: Procopius2k   2019-07-25 19:28  

#10  You would expect academics at a major American university to understand the concept of context. It's all about the context, dumbass.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2019-07-25 12:14  

#9  A lot of words serve dual purposes. Take the word dumb. It can mean unable to speak or it can mean stupid. So if I say this Inclusive Language Guide is dumb, everybody knows what I mean.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2019-07-25 12:12  

#8  Where's the logic of someone who's already certain they are better than me wanting to be "included" in my cohort?
Posted by: M. Murcek   2019-07-25 11:12  

#7  Maybe not, but dumbass is fully inclusive so I'll apply that to you dumbasses.
Posted by: DarthVader   2019-07-25 10:13  

#6  Minds Destroyed By The Internet
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2019-07-25 10:02  

#5  Colorado is not inclusive enough! Must change it to something like Dip-S#!+ or Idiot or Moron. Besides Colorado is a Spanish word for red and is therefore cultural appropriation.
Posted by: AlmostAnonymous5839   2019-07-25 09:53  

#4  Then they'll be relieved if no more of that nasty United States of America currency makes it to their campus, I'm sure.
Posted by: M. Murcek   2019-07-25 07:41  

#3  Orwell was a Word War veteran.
Posted by: Dron66046   2019-07-25 02:29  

#2  The root of all evil is...

Government Student loans that can not be repaid are the only things that keeps the inflated salaries of the tenured afloat. In return they overly paid academia must pump out stupid kids who believe in leftist ideology that has overtaken the federal government. You are not American, male, female, you are nothing but a slave of the masters on the left. The only thing missing are the chains.
Posted by: Phaick Uneretle6310   2019-07-25 00:52  

#1  "The Americas encompass a lot more than the United States," the guide states. "There is South America, Central America, Mexico, Canada, and the Caribbean just to name a few of 42 countries in total."

Yes but only one has America as part of the name. This argument is stupid and always has been. United States of Mexico is known as Mexico, Federative Republic of Brazil is known as Brazi, United States of America is known as America. It's pretty simple really if you aren't a self-hating idiot.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2019-07-25 00:25  

00:00