You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Rhode Island Bishop: You Cannot Be Catholic and ‘Pro-Abortion'
2020-05-10
[Breitbart] The bishop of Providence, Rhode Island, has reiterated in comments loaded with political overtones church teaching that a person cannot be Catholic and pro-abortion because it would be a "contradiction in terms."

"Just saw a headline in a Catholic newspaper with the phrase ’pro-abortion Catholic.’ Sorry. That’s a contradiction in terms," wrote Bishop Thomas J. Tobin on Twitter this week. "You can’t be a Catholic, at least not an authentic one, and be ’pro-abortion.’ Or ’pro-choice.’ It’s the same thing."

Even though the assertion might seem noncontroversial to a casual observer, as the Catholic church’s position on abortion is well known, the bishop’s comments provoked a number of angry responses, presumably from Catholics who intend to vote for the pro-abortion Democrat ticket in this November’s elections.

Every election year brings with it hot debates among Catholics about the moral permissibility of voting for a candidate who promotes legal abortion. With Joe Biden the presumptive presidential candidate for the Democrats, the disputes are expected to rage as never before; Biden describes himself as a Catholic and yet vigorously supports abortion-on-demand.

Among important demographic groups, Catholics — while not comprising a monolithic voting "bloc"— make up nearly 25 percent of U.S. voters and in 2016 played a key role in sending Donald Trump to the White House, with the abortion issue looming large in voters’ minds.

Catholics voted for Donald Trump in 2016 by a larger margin than for any other Republican candidate in the five elections of the new millennium, according to a Pew Research Center study, and Catholic Democrats rightly fear that the margin could be even greater in 2020.

Catholic Democrats already came out swinging at New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan last week for having engaged in a conference call with President Trump on the topic of Catholic education, with the ultra-liberal National Catholic Reporter (NCR) lashing out at Dolan for "capitulating" to the Republican Party.
Posted by:Besoeker

#10  Comment #1 was "Does the Pope know this?"
Which made me think 'Does the Pope know this anything - beyond his commie 'Gaia' dogma?'
Posted by: Whiskey Mike   2020-05-10 16:39  

#9  the Church of England apparently only believes in a well dressed get together of a Sunday morning.

They also have that big summer solstice festival every year at Stonehenge. Or am I confusing the C of E with the Druids?
Posted by: SteveS   2020-05-10 14:20  

#8  I could not have predicted that the main theological controversy of the age would come down to the unhappy circumstance of actually having to believe in a number of irreducible precepts. At least the Catholics still argue a might, the Church of England apparently only believes in a well dressed get together of a Sunday morning.
Posted by: Cesare   2020-05-10 09:57  

#7  Priests. All week long they eat meat. But on Friday they have Nun...

Sgt. Stadanko
Posted by: M. Murcek   2020-05-10 09:25  

#6  they have a remedy for this, i'd suggest going after some high-profile 'Catholics' like Nancy & Lurch

is it about the faith or is it about the money?
Posted by: Bob Grorong1136   2020-05-10 08:22  

#5  I will take "Baptists & Bootleggers" for $300, Alex.
Posted by: Clem   2020-05-10 07:35  

#4  Yes, if you've got rhythm (method)
Posted by: Lex   2020-05-10 06:37  

#3  I think it might depend on whether you are wearing them at the time.
Posted by: SteveS   2020-05-10 02:26  

#2  Can I be a Catholic (not that I'm really interested) while dispensing free condoms?
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2020-05-10 02:20  

#1  Does the Pope know this?
Posted by: SteveS   2020-05-10 01:44  

00:00