| Submit your comments on this article |
| Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
| The Miracle of Ukrainian Survival |
| 2022-04-13 |
| [The Atlantic] This friday, as Passover begins, my thoughts will turn to my late grandmother. Born in Ukraine, she survived the Nazis, the only one in her immediate family to escape the guns of the génocidaires. Each year, at the beginning of the seder, she would stand from her chair, if she could, and recount the story of her flight, never explicitly drawing comparisons to the exodus from Egypt. As she finished her testimony—which, like the seder itself, entailed the ritualistic repetition of details and phrases—she would stare across the table and tell us, "You are my revenge against Hitler." This year, I began to think about those words long before the holiday season. They returned to me on the night of February 25, the second day of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. In the darkness of Kyiv, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky stepped into the empty streets, trailed by a coterie of advisers. A rumor, nefariously spread, held that Zelensky had fled for his life, a decision that would have arguably made rational sense. After all, sources in U.S. intelligence were telling reporters that his government would likely be toppled in a week’s time. To counteract the sense of doom descending on Ukraine, he recorded a video on a phone. Using the gentlest version of his gravelly voice, he told his people, "We are still here." Like my grandmother’s admonition, Zelensky’s words were a prayer and a defiant rallying cry. I felt as if they had been uttered, unconsciously, in the spirit of Passover. Abigail Pogrebin: Why is this year different from all other years? The Haggadah instructs its readers to tell the story of the exodus as if they were themselves slaves in Egypt. It demands an imaginative leap that places those at the table in a chain of events, asking them to vicariously conjure the terror of fleeing the Egyptians, but also the jubilation of liberation. Like the subtext of my grandmother’s conclusion, the seder not-so-subtly imposes a burden on its participants. Because their ancestors persisted through the worst, the present generation can’t be the ones who give up. In other words, the ritualistic retelling of the story of Jewish survival becomes the basis for Jewish survival. Zelensky, a performer by trade, has been telling a story about his own people, in the hopes that it can help carry his nation through its own struggle against a pharaoh. Among the hopeful words in his story is we. His daily video messages to his people repeat flourishes like, "We are all Ukrainians. We are all Europeans. We are all free people of the free world." But that description of national sentiment wasn’t always an objective description of political reality. Ever since Ukraine became an independent nation, in 1991, its politics have been divided along linguistic and geographic lines. Political parties representing the Ukrainian-speaking west vied for power against factions representing the Russian-speaking east. Clearly, Vladimir Putin hoped that this divide would bolster his invasion, that denizens of eastern cities would greet the Russian army as liberators. In Putin’s analysis of the world, a nation’s military strength is an outgrowth of its national character. The mightiest states have traditionalist foundations, a sense of nationhood grounded in religion and patriarchal values, the affection that comes from blood and soil. That’s another weakness he identified in Ukraine: its cosmopolitanism. Ukraine aspires to align with the European Union and its dream of transcending national borders. Its president has espoused tolerance for LGBTQ people; he was an entertainer who once pretended to play the piano with his penis. Ukraine is weak because it is decadence incarnate. |
| Posted by:Besoeker |
| #8 And while I've never been a huge fan of Errol Flynn, there're worse entertainers for a two-bit Ukrainian comedian to be compared to. Couldn't stand the guy... but y'all have just about turned me around. Keep up the good work! |
| Posted by: Blossom Snusomp5491 2022-04-13 22:03 |
| #7 #2 an entertainer who once pretended to play the piano with his penis As opposed to an organist who pretends to play his country like a fiddle? |
| Posted by: Blossom Snusomp5491 2022-04-13 21:53 |
| #6 an endless financial drain on the West ..nothing compared to the financial drain of an endless and ever expanding entitlement system they're already saddled with. |
| Posted by: Procopius2k 2022-04-13 17:17 |
| #5 They're Europe's Palestinians Or they’re literally the Cossacks that for centuries guarded Russia’s western frontier in exchange for self-rule. And now 100,000 of their women, children, and elderly are reported exiled to Siberia and points north, according to one of badanov’s translations today. Do you think they’ll be inclined to stay where Russia put them? |
| Posted by: trailing wife 2022-04-13 13:47 |
| #4 Ukrainians aren't the new Jews fighting Nazis. They're Europe's Palestinians fighting a vastly more powerful and ruthless neighbor. Donbas is like the West Bank. Zelensky is like Arafat, except he can play Chopin with his dick Palestine's backers think they have the moral high ground and cheer every time those nefarious Israelis get killed by a Pal warrior. But the result will be the same: a frozen conflict and an endless financial drain on the West |
| Posted by: Captain Spese3250 2022-04-13 11:34 |
| #3 ^ 🤡 |
| Posted by: Captain Spese3250 2022-04-13 11:25 |
| #2 "Ukraine's president has espoused tolerance for LGBTQ people; he was an entertainer who once pretended to play the piano with his penis." |
| Posted by: Herb Grundy5952 2022-04-13 11:07 |
| #1 From my mail bag: It is no miracle - people fighting for hearth and home are tough resilient fighters. |
| Posted by: Besoeker 2022-04-13 10:58 |