Hi there, !
Today Tue 07/31/2012 Mon 07/30/2012 Sun 07/29/2012 Sat 07/28/2012 Fri 07/27/2012 Thu 07/26/2012 Wed 07/25/2012 Archives
447204 articles and 1580179 comments are archived on Rantburg.

Today: 36 articles and 98 comments as of 0:41.
Post a news link    Post your own article   
Area: WoT Operations    WoT Background    Non-WoT        Politix    Posting Order
Helicopter gunships strafe Aleppo
Today's Headlines
Headline Comments [Views]
Page 4: Opinion
5 19:51 Zhang Fei [664] 
Page 1: WoT Operations
1 20:59 Redneck Jim [455]
2 15:39 regular joe [365]
1 10:38 DepotGuy [655]
0 [375]
2 15:07 Raider [671]
0 [401]
4 16:01 manversgwtw [367]
1 18:54 Zhang Fei [791]
2 07:01 Fester Clunter7205 [361]
1 12:02 bman [363]
0 [359]
Page 2: WoT Background
6 13:41 Richard Aubrey [461]
0 [353]
0 [362]
1 12:02 newc [367]
1 08:07 Redneck Jim [360]
5 15:08 Raider [661]
1 20:02 Dale [425]
3 16:15 manversgwtw [431]
0 [350]
0 [351]
15 23:16 gorb [450]
0 [350]
1 08:09 Redneck Jim [362]
0 [343]
Page 3: Non-WoT
5 17:44 Matt [722]
2 13:22 Bright Pebbles [663]
3 17:00 Besoeker [721]
1 15:15 Raider [373]
4 14:49 Steve White [363]
6 22:15 USN, ret. [462]
8 22:08 JosephMendiola [756]
7 23:18 swksvolFF [431]
Page 6: Politix
2 11:31 Redneck Jim [644]
8 21:49 Barbara [787]
Analysis: The Myth Of Palestinian Neutrality In Syria
[Ma'an] On July 14, thousands of Paleostinian refugees marched in a funeral procession for 11 unarmed protesters rubbed out by Syrian security forces in the al-Yarmouk refugee camp. Raucous and seething with rage, mourners chanted for Syria and Paleostine, called for the downfall of Bashir al-Assad's regime, and sang for freedom.

Whether this burgeoning civil disobedience movement will grow into an open, durable rebellion remains to be seen, but the significance and the potential influence of the latest wave of protests that has swept Syria's largest Paleostinian camp cannot be overlooked.

As the Syrian uprising gathered momentum and the Syrian regime escalated its repression against what started out as a peaceful revolt, concerns have emerged about the impact of the uprising on Paleostinian refugees in Syria, who make up just over 2 percent of Syria's total population.

The Paleostinian political elite in Syria have been divided. Some factions have desperately attempted to appear neutral, distancing themselves from the unrest. Others, such as Ahmad Jibril's PFLP-GC, Fatah al-Intifada, and the Paleostinian-Baathist militia al-Sa'iqa, have actively supported the regime, bolstering its propaganda campaigns and crushing civil dissent inside the camps.

In stark contrast to the moribund, aging politicianship, Paleostinian-Syrian youth activists, who prior to the eruption of the uprising had focused their activism on Paleostine, have participated in the uprising since the very beginning as demonstrators; organizers of aid and relief work for maimed and internally-displaced Syrians; or as citizen journalists, photographers and media activists. The hub of their activism, however, remained outside the camps for most of the uprising.

Never were the tensions among Syria's Paleostinians as discernible as during the aftermath of last year's Naksa Day protests on June 5, when dozens of unarmed Paleostinians were killed by the Israeli occupation army in the occupied Golan Heights border area. Yarmouk inhabitants and deaders' families set the PFLP-GC building ablaze in a strong denunciation of the faction's role in mobilizing to instigate the youths to march back home without any protection despite the anticipated deadly reaction by the Israeli army.

The faction engaged in a pathetically naked attempt to deflect attention from the regime's crackdown. Several Paleostinians were killed in the festivities that ensued between Yarmouk residents and armed PFLP-GC gunnies following the funeral. However,
a person who gets all wrapped up in himself makes a mighty small package...
with the exception of the Syrian navy's attack on the al-Raml refugee camp last summer and the occasional Syrian army shelling on refugee camps in Daraa, Hama and Homs, the situation in the refugee camps remained cautiously quiet.

Intifada in the camps

Since February, the al-Yarmouk camp has regularly held protests in solidarity with the besieged Syrian cities and towns. It participated in the Damascus
...The place where Pencilneck hangs his brass hat...
general strike on May 29, 2012. The protests would normally pass quietly without being attacked by Syrian security forces.

The straw that broke the camel's back was the abduction and then killing of 13 Paleostinian Liberation Army fighters from the Nayrab refugee camp in Aleppo
...For centuries, Aleppo was Greater Syria's largest city and the Ottoman Empire's third, after Constantinople and Cairo. Although relatively close to Damascus in distance, Aleppans regard Damascenes as country cousins...
. Though the identity of the killers is unknown, the killings sparked a large protest in Yarmouk on July 12, and an even larger protest the next day. Buoyant chants of "God bless the Free Syrian Army", "From Syria to Paleostine, one people not two", and "Long live Syria and down with Assad" echoed in the camp's streets. The Syrian army shot up protesters and for the first time, festivities between the regime army and the FSA broke out inside the camp, marking a significant tipping point. The Local Coordination Committee of Yarmouk camp called for mass protests and a general strike to protest the killings.

Jihad Makdissi, the front man of the Syrian Foreign Ministry, described Paleostinians in Syria as "guests" and cynically told them to "leave Syria for one of the Arab democracies" if they misbehave. Makdissi's Facebook statement, which he later deleted, fired up the rubes and highlighted the complicated nature of Paleostinian participation in the uprising.

"We always warned against pushing the camp into the uprising, but no one listened," tweeted an anti-Assad Yarmouk resident following the massacre. The International Committee of the Red Thingy recently described the situation in Syria as a civil war. Thus, concerns of being "stuck" in the middle of a civil war or intervening in "internal" affairs are perfectly legitimate and understandable. Active opposition to the Syrian regime poses serious risks to Paleostinian refugees.

The most imminent scenario is that the general violence that has marred the country for the last 16 months would spill over to the camps. Despite their under-privileged status as stateless refugees, Paleostinians in refugee camps have been relatively safer than neighboring Syrian districts in besieged cities, leading several internally displaced families to seek asylum in the Paleostinian camps. Meanwhile,
...back at the Esquimeau village our hero was receiving a quick lesson in aeronautics......
the regime has mostly avoided launching direct attacks on refugee camps, particularly Yarmouk, in order not to alienate an already divided population.

a person who gets all wrapped up in himself makes a mighty small package...
as shown by the attack on unarmed protesters in Yarmouk, the Syrian regime has not backed down on attacking Paleostinian refugees, dare they "misbehave."

The situation could further deteriorate in the event of festivities between the regime army and armed opposition fighters. Yarmouk camp is a strategically important area that borders Midan, Tadamun, and al-Hajar al-Aswad -- Damascene neighborhoods that have seen intense festivities between the army and the FSA in the last few days. This raises the possibility that the camp could turn into a niche area of battle. A less likely -- but perhaps more dangerous -- scenario is an intra-Paleostinian collision between regime loyalists and opponents. The festivities that followed the Naksa Day protests last year served to expose the tensions enveloping the Paleostinian community in Syria; the current unrest could foment them.

The searing memories of the destruction of Nahr al-Bared refugee camp in north Leb are still haunting and vivid five years on; the fears of a similar scenario taking place in Syria are not completely far-fetched despite the glaring differences between the two situations.

The myth of neutrality

In spite of the aforementioned perils, the participation of Paleostinian-Syrian youth in the uprising seems inevitable and unavoidable. Contrary to Paleostinian refugees in neighboring Leb who are dehumanized and denied basic rights, Paleostinians in Syria have long enjoyed rights equal to those of Syrian citizens in most respects, including health, education and employment. Equality is not a favor that the Assad family bestowed upon Paleostinians: Law 60, which grants Paleostinian refugees near equality with Syrian nationals, was passed in 1956 by a democratically elected parliament under the leadership of the widely admired former president, Shoukri al-Quwatli. Though strongly bound to the Paleostinian cause, many Paleostinians in Syria, particularly second- and third-generation refugees, have assimilated into Syrian society.

So, how all of a sudden, have Paleostinians become "outsiders" who should refrain from intervening in "internal" Syrian affairs?

The irony is especially striking since the Syrian regime has long crowned itself as the guardian of the Paleostinian cause and Pan-Arabism. Moreover, it has -- since the uprising -- used the Paleostinian cause to whitewash its crimes and defend the indefensible. Another question that begs to be asked is: What are 'internal' Syrian affairs, and what constitutes an intrusion in those affairs? Should Paleostinians cease providing shelter and aid for maimed and displaced Syrians in the name of respecting "internal" affairs? Should they abstain from protesting against Assad's military tyranny in the name of respecting Syria's illusory sovereignty? Not only are the boundaries extremely vague, neutrality in the Syrian crisis is a myth.

Additionally, it is impossible to expect Paleostinians who were born, raised, educated in Syria -- who have lived their entire lives there -- to sit on the fence. It is also a false dichotomy to think that a sense of belonging to Syria negates the Paleostinian identity and roots of refugees, who have a sacred, inalienable right of return to Paleostine. Moreover, to claim that they are "used by both sides" is a profound insult to the Paleostinians who freely chose to protest against the Syrian regime. Such a claim suggests that anti-regime Paleostinians have no free will or autonomy. The Paleostinian population in Syria is diverse and no one, including prominent Paleostinian intellectuals and activists outside Syria, has the right to speak in their name and decide for them.

When one considers all the complexities and uncertainty plaguing the situation in Syria, staying on the sidelines no longer appears to be a feasible option.

It is both painfully ironic and incredibly moving that Yarmouk, built to host ethnically cleansed Paleostinians, has now turned into a safe haven for Syrians fleeing the shelling on Tadamon and Midan; that UNRWA schools became shelters in the last few days; and that Paleostinian residents of the camp have donated mattresses, meals and medicine for their maimed Syrian neighbors. These acts of solidarity have been beacons of inspiration amid the endless cycle of violence and grief that has descended upon Syria.
Posted by: trailing wife || 07/28/2012 00:00 || Comments || Link || E-Mail|| [664 views] Top|| File under:

#1  Secularists are siding with the regime, and Islamists are siding with the opposition.
Posted by: Zhang Fei || 07/28/2012 0:18 Comments || Top||

#2  Secularists are siding with the regime, and Islamists are siding with the opposition.

I beg to differ.

For the last sixty years the Assads, the so-called "secularists," have worked to keep the Palestinians a) deprived of rights, b) more or less limited to refugee camps, in both Syria and Lebanon, and c) used anti-semitism as the scapegoat for the suffering they themselves inflict in the here-and-now on the grandchildren and great-grandchildren of the refugees of 1947.

They've been fed a steady drumbeat for the last sixty years of "Look at the misery around you! It's all the Jews' fault! You will be able to have the rights of normal people and normal lives once we deal them a harsh enough blow and they give up on Israel and move back to Russia, or Poland, or Long Island!"

That's what the "secularists" have done. To a very large extent they fed and nurtured the monster they use as justification for their present oppressive measures, much the same as Mubarak fed the Moslem Brotherhood in Egypt as part of his "Apres Moi Le Deluge" strategy.

You can't expect all of them to have been happy with this abuse, and it's not necessarily an islamicist plot if they don't always believe the propaganda from the people who have fed them a shit sandwich their whole lives.
Posted by: Thing From Snowy Mountain || 07/28/2012 10:14 Comments || Top||

#3  The Palestinians don't need Assad to tell them to hate Jews. Muslims across the world who have never met either Jew or Palestinian hate Jews, a hatred that has been handed down from father to son for 13 centuries among the ummah. Assad merely caters to their inclinations - a wise decision, given that the Sunni Arab majority has traditionally viewed Alawites as pests to be killed on sight. Any softness towards Israel would certainly be viewed as evidence that Assad is a closet Zionist and an enemy of Islam which, as a follower of a minority heretical/apostatical sect relying on a modus vivendi with both Sunni and Shiite Islam to keep the internal peace, he really cannot afford.

The question isn't whether the secularists or the Islamists will hate Jews - it's which side is more likely to fund, train and arm Islamist rebels across the Arabia in order to realize their dream of a unitary Muslim caliphate, at least in the Middle East. An Alawite-ruled Syria will never be part of that caliphate.

It's the same reason it is preferable for us to have the al Saud royals remain in power as opposed to yielding power to democratically-elected Muslim Brotherhood and/or other Salafist political parties. The one thing all Muslims have in common is Jew-hatred, regardless of race, ethnicity or nationality. Note it's actually a pretty generalized hatred of non-Muslims, but an expression of genocidal intent against any other group would have very powerful countries lining up against the ummah. Why alert the infidel world to troglodyte Islam's dream of universal empire?

The problem with neo-cons is that they view the world as blank slates waiting for us to write on. In practice, foreigners tend to perpetuate the beliefs and prejudices handed down from generation to generation. It's the way of the world, and no amount of wishful thinking will change that.
Posted by: Zhang Fei || 07/28/2012 19:29 Comments || Top||

#4  For Muslims (or any other group of foreigners), it comes down to this - who are you going to believe, your direct kin or nice-sounding words from the descendants of the people who fought your ancestors?
Posted by: Zhang Fei || 07/28/2012 19:33 Comments || Top||

#5  People who come to power, dictator or democrat, take power under a very specific set of circumstances. Shift a single condition another way, and they might be out of power. This is why governments change all the time, whether dictatorship or democracies. The fact is that no leader has a complete understanding of what holds his regime together. In dictatorships, the alternative to continued rule is often death or exile, generally for their entire extended families. This is why many of them have extremely strong reactions to internal dissent and simultaneously attempt to mirror exactly the prejudices of their populations. For Assad to pivot and stop parroting his populace's Jew-hatred is an invitation for some rabble-rouser inside or outside of his clique to brand him as a traitor to his people, and a "Zionist lapdog".

Given the way in which his own father took power, it's pretty obvious that the people he rules are not drones who parrot his every thought, they are just biding their time. Again, neo-cons have to get this illusion that rulers control what their populations think out of their minds. Yes, we had to make up the lie that ordinary Germans and Japanese were misled by their rulers in order to make a soft peace more palatable to Allied electorates, in spite of the fact that those Axis populations were whole-hearted participants in the wars and atrocities they unleashed up to the point defeat became a certainty. But Muslims aren't defeated - we haven't killed 5-10% of their populations or burned their cities to the ground, and they certainly haven't groveled before us and admitted the injustice of their cause. It's way too early to make up these comforting lies about them, when we haven't even begun to fight them, let alone defeat them.
Posted by: Zhang Fei || 07/28/2012 19:51 Comments || Top||

Who's in the News
1Thai Insurgency

E-Mail Me

The Classics
The O Club
Rantburg Store
The Bloids
The Never-ending Story
Gulf War I
The Way We Were

Hair Through the Ages

On Sale now!

A multi-volume chronology and reference guide set detailing three years of the Mexican Drug War between 2010 and 2012.

Rantburg.com and borderlandbeat.com correspondent and author Chris Covert presents his first non-fiction work detailing the drug and gang related violence in Mexico.

Chris gives us Mexican press dispatches of drug and gang war violence over three years, presented in a multi volume set intended to chronicle the death, violence and mayhem which has dominated Mexico for six years.
Click here for more information

Meet the Mods
In no particular order...
Steve White
Scooter McGruder
john frum
Bright Pebbles
trailing wife
Frank G
Alaska Paul

Two weeks of WOT
Sat 2012-07-28
  Helicopter gunships strafe Aleppo
Fri 2012-07-27
  62 Mexican Policias Federales kidnapped in Michoacan
Thu 2012-07-26
  Syrian envoy to Cyprus defects
Wed 2012-07-25
  Syrian forces attack mosque, kill 30
Tue 2012-07-24
  Syrian Army Retakes Most of Damascus
Mon 2012-07-23
  23 wounded in Iraq car bombing
Sun 2012-07-22
  Pencilneck may use chemical weapons against rebels
Sat 2012-07-21
  Islamic Jihad Leadership Abandons Syria For Iran
Fri 2012-07-20
  Syria Rebels Take 'All Iraq Border Points'
Thu 2012-07-19
  Pencilneck runs away to Latakia
Wed 2012-07-18
  Two Buses With 40 Israeli Tourists Blown Up At Bulgarian Airport
Tue 2012-07-17
  Blast kills MP in Mogadishu, Militants claim responsibility
Mon 2012-07-16
  US Ship Fires on Boat off Dubai, 1 Dead
Sun 2012-07-15
  At Least 83 Killed across Syria
Sat 2012-07-14
  NDS Chief Among Bombing Victims at Afghan Wedding

Better than the average link...

Rantburg was assembled from recycled algorithms in the United States of America. No trees were destroyed in the production of this weblog. We did hurt some, though. Sorry.
WoT Operations (11)    WoT Background (14)    Non-WoT (8)    (0)    Politix (2)