Archived material Access restricted Article
Rantburg

Today's Front Page   View All of Sun 04/11/2004 View Sat 04/10/2004 View Fri 04/09/2004 View Thu 04/08/2004 View Wed 04/07/2004 View Tue 04/06/2004 View Mon 04/05/2004
1
2004-04-11 Iraq-Jordan
Marines: Fallujah rebels must ’submit or die’
Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.
Posted by Jarhead 2004-04-11 12:00:00 AM|| || Front Page|| [1 views since 2007-05-07]  Top

#1 Lol! You can always tell when a Marine is talking - they don't leave any wiggle room for the weenies!
Posted by .com 2004-04-11 12:23:14 AM||   2004-04-11 12:23:14 AM|| Front Page Top

#2 I would prefer the second option.
Posted by Concerned Citizen 2004-04-11 12:23:14 AM||   2004-04-11 12:23:14 AM|| Front Page Top

#3 Works for me!

Semper fi, Marines. You rock!
Posted by Barbara Skolaut  2004-04-11 12:26:33 AM||   2004-04-11 12:26:33 AM|| Front Page Top

#4 Sound like the Marines have thier stuff squared away!
Posted by Cyber Sarge  2004-04-11 12:34:51 AM||   2004-04-11 12:34:51 AM|| Front Page Top

#5 I vote for submit and die!
Posted by Zenster 2004-04-11 12:37:03 AM||   2004-04-11 12:37:03 AM|| Front Page Top

#6 The Arabs will not believe it and will not submit...

...until the second time they are given this ultimatum from the USMC, surrounded by their dead comrades that resulted from the conseqences of not taking a Marine at his word.
Posted by OldSpook 2004-04-11 2:54:19 AM||   2004-04-11 2:54:19 AM|| Front Page Top

#7 I hear the word "islam" actually means to "submit."
Posted by Anon 2004-04-11 7:20:05 AM||   2004-04-11 7:20:05 AM|| Front Page Top

#8 the U.S. military said it would move to take the city if cease-fire talks fail

Well latest word is that the cease-fire is in effect, so all this talk of ultimatums is hot air...for now anyways.
Posted by Rafael 2004-04-11 7:49:25 AM||   2004-04-11 7:49:25 AM|| Front Page Top

#9 Anon> your correct that is what it means.

We shall see what the talking heads come up/w. My estimate is that we'll be back to killing muzzy's by Monday. We'll prolly get a fix on more of their positions during the cease fire and might be able to get some Battle Damage Assessments (BDAs) back to our intel. In the interim we can reload, top off chow, h2o, & ammo and get ready for round two. So long as we've cordoned off all major thorough fare's to Fallujah so the enemy can't reconstitute - this is really no big deal for us. I bet the fallujian's medical supplies are all about used up. Heck, must find positives in every turn of the situation. We can just go Dug-out Doug on them, cordon off on block at a time and neutralize any resistors. Time becomes his enemy.
Posted by Jarhead 2004-04-11 9:30:33 AM||   2004-04-11 9:30:33 AM|| Front Page Top

#10  We can just go Dug-out Doug on them

LOL
With the help of God
(and a few Marines)
McArthur returned to the Phillipines.

I assume it wasn't in reference to
DougOut Doug lies a quaking on the rock....
Posted by Shipman 2004-04-11 11:35:23 AM||   2004-04-11 11:35:23 AM|| Front Page Top

#11 Well if they submit then we have too feed the scum. So dying looks like the best way too go
Posted by smokeysinse 2004-04-11 11:44:38 AM||   2004-04-11 11:44:38 AM|| Front Page Top

#12 If they submit -- hang them from that bridge and then open only that bridge to the outside so everyone has pass by them to get in our out.

Time for an object lession.
Posted by CrazyFool  2004-04-11 12:08:04 PM||   2004-04-11 12:08:04 PM|| Front Page Top

#13 Oh, they asked for the army
to come to Tulagi
But General MacArthur said "no"
He gave as his reason
It wasn't the season
Besides there is no USO

Asside from irreverant Marine humor, the press can blather an wring their hands. The bottom line is that the Marines stay their course in Fallujah and follow their battle plan. These things take time, and the press has neither the time or the patience.
Posted by Alaska Paul 2004-04-11 2:48:04 PM||   2004-04-11 2:48:04 PM|| Front Page Top

#14 Well latest word is that the cease-fire is in effect, so all this talk of ultimatums is hot air...for now anyways.

Hardly hot air, if you ask me. You can read the NYT headlines all you want to and ponder possibilities over glass of brandy and a cigar. But, if you want MHO, this is is do or die. We aren't playing barbie dolls or GI joe here.

They have a choice, submit or die. Sometimes things are just that simple.
Posted by B 2004-04-11 3:53:55 PM||   2004-04-11 3:53:55 PM|| Front Page Top

#15 silly :-p

if they submit worst we can do is jug them till the world forgets about them then hand them over to the iraqi's to be executed as saddam sympathizers.. Anything more and we lose credibility
Posted by Dcreeper 2004-04-11 7:13:32 PM||   2004-04-11 7:13:32 PM|| Front Page Top

#16 #1 Yup .com gotta luv'em for it.

The biggest enemy we have is American public opinion. At work people still go "Yeah but over 650 soldiers have died." Although every American death is a horrible thing, you have to look at it from a military standpoint. These numbers are EXTREMELY light casualties.
Why doesn't the press just say 380 KIA instead of counting about 250 people run over by trucks or "accidental discharges"! The press takes great pains to pump the body count.
I'm starting to get fed up with Rummy and Bush. Rummy, because his "economy of force" policy plus high tech isn't worth a damn. What he needs to do is to start raising 5 to 6 more Infantry Divisions YESTERDAY!!! (think future operations elsewhere) Boots on the grounds win the war not a couple 10 million dollar missles. (Clinton tried that remember?) If he thinks rotating 2 large chunks of the military back and forth to Iraq isn't going to send recruitment / reenlistment rates plummeting, he's nuts.
The 1200 Marines wasn't enough. (Offensive Attacks ((never mind that it's MOUT OPS)) should have a ,what, 3:1 ratio of attackers to defenders? Hmmm...)They should have brought in, at least, 2 Brigades (aprox 5,000) to start with. Then run the campaign 24/7.
Also, all of these "cease fires" make us look weak to the Iraq's and Arabs sorta like the militants are wearing us down. (the first one to get the women and children out ok, but thats it.)
As far as Bush, it's election time and now he's "asking other nations for suggestions on how to resolve it!!??" Hell man, you have Marines on the job, don't hinder them and let them get the job done! As long as the politician's continue to get in the way (or worry about if people will vote for them) things will only get worse for the soldiers and Marines. May God bless them all. ...My 2 cents.
Posted by 98Zulu 2004-04-11 7:56:33 PM||   2004-04-11 7:56:33 PM|| Front Page Top

#17 They have a choice, submit or die.

..or take the cease-fire (which is what they have been offered). In a cease-fire nobody's doing the killing, dying, or submitting. So I don't understand your point.

98Zulu, once again, I agree with you.
Posted by Rafael 2004-04-11 9:05:07 PM||   2004-04-11 9:05:07 PM|| Front Page Top

#18 well...Rafael...I guess I'll have to give you the point that if they suspend themselves in time and stay in the ceasefire for eternity, then, you are in fact, correct.
Posted by B 2004-04-11 9:21:10 PM||   2004-04-11 9:21:10 PM|| Front Page Top

#19 98Zulu - Oops! I just saw your post! I love Rummy, for a lot of reasons, but I have to say I'm coming to the same conclusion about boots. Either there is a moronic problem with Abizaid / Sanchez on the distribution of boots in Iraq (or even the dipshit possessive politics within the Corps that pops up when someone suggests stripping off a unit here or there to put them where they're needed - that shit goes on, too), or there just ain't enough to go around in-country. I'll say the 3:1 has been the standard for a few thousand years and makes a shitload of assumptions -- which may not apply today because there are some serious tech advantages ranging from night vision to air support to comms. So I'll wiggle a little bit right there, but I buy off on the whole as making real and solid sense. My understanding is that during our little hudna, the Marine forces have been reinforced to approximately double in number - what, 2500? - which does make you wonder, I agree, about the first pass.

Sorry for slow reply!!!
Posted by .com 2004-04-11 9:22:07 PM||   2004-04-11 9:22:07 PM|| Front Page Top

#20 if they suspend themselves in time and stay in the ceasefire for eternity

Ooooooooh, I see. Stupid me. I thought this cease-fire was for real. In that case, I stand corrected.
Posted by Rafael 2004-04-11 9:54:21 PM||   2004-04-11 9:54:21 PM|| Front Page Top

#21 Look raffy .... you aren't making any sense. A ceasefire is a temporary thing by nature. There has to be an OUTCOME from a ceasefire.

It could be, I suppose, that the marines will just up and go home or that the bad guys will put down their arms and start tending to their sheep (ie: "submit")

At some point, the ceasefire will end because the bad guys either

1. the marines go home (yeah right)
2. the bad guys submit... or
3. they die

Perhaps you could explain to me other outcomes from this ceasefire.
Posted by B 2004-04-11 10:18:55 PM||   2004-04-11 10:18:55 PM|| Front Page Top

#22 A ceasefire is a temporary thing by nature.

Depends who is proposing it. It would be politically stupid for the coalition to ask for a cease-fire, then resume hostilities. So I assume the cease-fire is permanent. The outcome being resumption of the rule of law.
I do not see "submitting" as the same thing as cease-fire, btw. Submitting means surrendering; cease-fire means going back to tending sheep, for now, ready to fight another day.

I really don't understand why you're picking a fight here. Going back to what I said originally, "submit or die" means nothing if a cease-fire has been declared. Either there is a cease-fire, or there is not.

Anyway, we're arguing about semantics here. The jihadis themselves will render this disagreement moot. Let's oblige them.
Posted by Rafael 2004-04-11 10:43:31 PM||   2004-04-11 10:43:31 PM|| Front Page Top

#23 if you say so.
Posted by B 2004-04-11 10:47:12 PM||   2004-04-11 10:47:12 PM|| Front Page Top

08:48 Gentle
15:45 Old Grouch
06:55 B
06:45 Phil B
06:23 Zenster
06:23 Mike
06:08 B
01:01 Super Hose
00:57 Super Hose
00:38 Aris Katsaris
00:33 Zenster
00:33 Super Hose
00:24 Super Hose
00:19 Super Hose
00:13 .com
00:10 .com
00:09 mojo
00:07 Jen
00:06 B
00:03 Raj
23:59 .com
23:58 Raj
23:57 Zenster
23:53 Aris Katsaris









Paypal:
Google
Search WWW Search rantburg.com