Article

2004-08-25 Terror Networks

The Key to Jihadist Ideology and Strategy

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by Ptah 2004-08-25 11:40:42 AM|| || Front Page|| [1 views since 2007-05-07] Top

#1 Good reading, Ptah. It looks like my theory of "us" vs. "not-us" was close-but-no-cigar. There are, in fact, two flavors of "not-us": the Greater and Lesser Unbelief. And that, in turn, is only one of the Methods that may be employed.

Bookmarked.

Posted by eLarson 2004-08-25 12:20:48 PM|| [http://larsonian.blogspot.com] 2004-08-25 12:20:48 PM|| Front Page Top

#2 Moslems are supposed to model their life after Mohammad. While this type of model is basically nonsense, it does explain the jihadi actions, especially if you take the warlike hadiths seriously.

Posted by mhw 2004-08-25 12:31:12 PM|| 2004-08-25 12:31:12 PM|| Front Page Top

#3 Good one Ptah, I'm sure, but not certain, "an eye for an eye" is a rockbed principle within islam. I'm afraid of sniping our interstates myself. Our borders have been so left unprotected. And those cadres are prolly in place.

Posted by Lucky 2004-08-25 12:41:45 PM|| 2004-08-25 12:41:45 PM|| Front Page Top

#4 Excellent article and thoughts. Thanks.

In other words, the left believes that the Islamists hate us for our sins, and the right believes that they hate us for our virtues. Both sides commit the same narcissistic fallacy of thinking that the Islamist holy war against the West revolves solely around ourselves, around the moral drama of our goodness or our wickedness, rather than having something to do with Islam itself.

I was recently reading Ralph Peters' Beyond Baghdad. I was struck by his belief that monotheism is basically the cause of all of the world's ills. I certainly can't argue with this on one level. But I also think there is an inherent flaw in accepting, without question, the belief that monotheistic religion's "my way or the highway" mentality is the cause of all the worlds wars.

Rather, I believe that what we are seeing is the clash of good ideas v/s not as good. Western thought is based on the values of Christianity; faith, hope, charity, forgiveness - and these values allow one a greater chance of success in achieving a more fulfilling individual life. The greater the number of individuals participating in a set of healthy beliefs the greater the correlation to a healthy, prosperous, happy, society.

According to the quote above, I am falling prey to "narcissistic fallacy" by imposing my own beliefs.

Yet, I would disagree. Instead I would argue that, the very complaint that I am falling prey to a narcissistic fallacy, by putting forth my own belief that Christian values make for a better society), is itself, a "narcissistic fallacy" - the fallacy of "moral relativism.

I believe that some ideas are better than others. And to prove my point, look at Islamic based societies v/s Christian. One is based on blame and shame, another on helping one another and digging deep to forgive rather than to seek revenge.

I think we could even apply the same beleifs to left v/s right. Cultures whose values are based on shaming, blaming others for the source of their ills, simply do not fare as well as those based on the tenants of Christianity.

One set of ideas has a clear track record of success, one of failure. Screw the PC crap. This is a clash of better ideas challenging the staus quo of lesser ideas....be they cultural, religious or political. May the best ideas win.

Posted by B 2004-08-25 2:13:55 PM|| 2004-08-25 2:13:55 PM|| Front Page Top

04:59 Sock Puppet of Doom
03:24 trailing wife
01:51 Asedwich
00:25 Super Hose
00:22 CrazyFool
00:21 Lucky
00:12 Lucky
00:06 Lucky
23:43 GreatestJeneration
23:40 .com
23:36 True German Ally
23:34 Halfass Pete
23:32 .com
23:29 GK
23:26 Anonymoose
23:25 Fred
23:08 GreatestJeneration
23:06 Steve White
23:06 ed
23:00 Darth VAda
22:55 Yank
22:54 .Abu Billy
22:51 True German Ally
22:47 .Abu Billy