Article

2005-03-22 Arabia

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by Steve 2005-03-22 1:16:45 PM|| || Front Page|| [6 views since 2007-05-07] Top

#1 That feminist organization may not, Steve, but this feminist will.

It goes deeper than Islam, however, I am afraid. Some Christian churches also refuse to allow women positions of authority.

Posted by Jules 187 2005-03-22 2:06:18 PM|| 2005-03-22 2:06:18 PM|| Front Page Top

#2 Jules, difference is that within 'Some Christian churches', a woman won't get death threats. It may be very sublime difference in your view, but I think it is rather a substantial one.

Posted by Sobiesky 2005-03-22 2:17:27 PM|| 2005-03-22 2:17:27 PM|| Front Page Top

#3 I don't disagree with you, Sobiesky. Of course it is a substantial difference. Christianity is light years ahead of Islam as far as the lives of women go. But some sects of Christianity could stand a little bit of growth in the direction of being EOE for women leaders, don't you think?

Posted by Jules 187 2005-03-22 2:44:58 PM|| 2005-03-22 2:44:58 PM|| Front Page Top

#4 Orthodox Jews also only let women lead prayers in all female groups (and some dont even hold with that) but like Sobie says, they dont threaten to kill people about it, and thats the key difference. (my own branch of Judaism, Conservative J, does allow them lead to prayers, though there are SOME residual gender inequalities in C Jewish law - Reform J holds with full equality in all matters)

Posted by liberalhawk 2005-03-22 2:49:07 PM|| 2005-03-22 2:49:07 PM|| Front Page Top

#5 Could it be said as generally true of more traditionally-bound Abrahamic religions? I wonder how non-Abrahamic-based religions approach it.

Posted by Jules 187 2005-03-22 3:04:12 PM|| 2005-03-22 3:04:12 PM|| Front Page Top

#6 actually Orthodox Judaism, especially modern orthodox Judaism, is more complex than that

in many, maybe most, Orthodox congregations, a woman may lead the after meal benedictions even with men present if there are 3 or more women and less than 3 men; in a few Orthodox congregations, a woman may lead as long as there are more than 3 woman, even if there are 3 men

the injunction against woman and men praying together only exists with the 18/19 benedictions; not with the kaddish, nor with the preliminary prayers

a woman can lead in a stand alone recital of the psalms also in most orthodox congregations

there are, however, many haradi orthodox congregations where non of the above noted leniencies exist

Posted by mhw 2005-03-22 3:37:01 PM|| 2005-03-22 3:37:01 PM|| Front Page Top

#7 well its been awhile since ive davened at and MO shul, so take what i say with salt:

Most of the leniencies mhw mentions i dont recall seeing. OTOH many of the MO congregations ive been in have been fairly large established ones, and usually just on shabbat or yom tov, and it may not have come up. I would guess these leniencies are more utilized by smaller cutting edge MO shuls, or in special services, etc?

Still im aware of lots of ferment in MO, so i dont suppose any of these should surprise me.

Posted by liberalhawk 2005-03-22 4:07:57 PM|| 2005-03-22 4:07:57 PM|| Front Page Top

#8 Friday prayer is a religious duty for men only, while women can only attend if they wish to but not as a duty ... Prayers are totally not valid if they are led by a woman,

injunction against woman and men praying together only exists with the 18/19 benedictions

but its the shmoneh esreh, along with the shma, thats the halachacilly REQUIRED prayer, tehillim (psalms) etc are NOT. So the parallellism still holds, I think - though i wonder if the muslim daily prayers included optional portions as well as required ones, or if they have a parallel to the distinction between required by law (halacha) and custom (minhag)

Posted by liberalhawk 2005-03-22 4:15:19 PM|| 2005-03-22 4:15:19 PM|| Front Page Top

#9 Now my hed hurtz.

Posted by Shipman 2005-03-22 5:26:34 PM|| 2005-03-22 5:26:34 PM|| Front Page Top

#10 One of the MSM organs had a piece on this, and one of the individuals interviewed (surrounded by co-religionists on a happenin' street in NYC) was an Angry Young Muslim Man. "This is blasphemy!" he shouted into the camera. "And the penalty for blasphemy is DEATH!"

I mean, really. This isn't Amsterdam, buster.

Posted by mrp 2005-03-22 5:34:55 PM|| 2005-03-22 5:34:55 PM|| Front Page Top

#11 LH

I can't comment about your question on moslem prayer. However, regarding the Shema, there is no injunction against mixed prayer.

The injunction on mixed prayer in the amidah is partially because the amidah substitutes for the offerings.

The shema doesn't require a minyon (actually neither does the amidah unless you want to repeat it out loud).

I just realized how geeky this all sounds. Uggggh

Posted by mhw 2005-03-22 5:36:53 PM|| 2005-03-22 5:36:53 PM|| Front Page Top

#12 Prayers don't work when they're led by a babe...

Heh.

Posted by Seafarious 2005-03-22 5:58:26 PM|| 2005-03-22 5:58:26 PM|| Front Page Top

#13 let me tell ya, when you're tied naked to a bed and the babe's got a knife and says "start prayin'" ....you do

oops....was I free associating again?

Posted by Frank G 2005-03-22 6:02:11 PM|| 2005-03-22 6:02:11 PM|| Front Page Top

#14 Frank, is that your idea of a Lenten post?

Posted by Matt 2005-03-22 6:37:49 PM|| 2005-03-22 6:37:49 PM|| Front Page Top

#15 More like a fantasy, I suspect.

Posted by too true 2005-03-22 6:49:39 PM|| 2005-03-22 6:49:39 PM|| Front Page Top

#16 My biggest problem with all of this is that the legs in the picture looks sorta like drumsticks ... give the ladies a little credit ...

Posted by Unugum Sneth6886 2005-03-22 11:18:51 PM|| 2005-03-22 11:18:51 PM|| Front Page Top

23:46 Bobby
23:43 Glitle Craviter4997
23:40 Elmoting Granter5118
23:39 SteveS
23:36 Bobby
23:34 Bobby
23:29 mrp
23:18 Unugum Sneth6886
23:13 phil_b
23:10 AzCat
23:04 True German Ally
23:03 mom
23:00 badanov
22:59 True German Ally
22:54 Peppah
22:54 Desert Blondie
22:52 Frank G
22:52 True German Ally
22:51 Frank G
22:49 Aris Katsaris
22:47 True German Ally
22:45 jn1
22:45 Peppah
22:38 Barbara Skolaut