Article

2005-02-04 Fifth Column

How the right played the fascism card against Islam

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by anonymous2u 2005-02-04 1:36:04 AM|| || Front Page|| [10 views since 2007-05-07] Top

#1 Oddly, it seems he can't grasp the obvious: it's accurate. I guess if his ilk can't apply it, then it's only a word which has lost any useful meaning. SocioFascistIslamoBatâ¢ wank-o-matic AlG twitter.

Posted by .com 2005-02-04 2:06:32 AM|| 2005-02-04 2:06:32 AM|| Front Page Top

#2 Albert Scardino is a SocioFascistWankerBat.

Posted by Sock Puppet of Doom 2005-02-04 2:13:42 AM|| [http://www.slhess.com] 2005-02-04 2:13:42 AM|| Front Page Top

#3 This would be a lot less amusing if he didn't actually believe that "Bush = Hitler" is the nuanced view...

Posted by someone 2005-02-04 3:54:42 AM|| 2005-02-04 3:54:42 AM|| Front Page Top

#4 Fascism is coming back into fashion, at least in the propaganda wars. For the right, it comes in the shape of a new word: "islamofascism". That conflates all the elements into one image: suicide bombs, kidnappings and the Qurâan; the fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan; Iranian clerics and Hitler.

All the elements of what? In this missive we already have leftist propoganda and we're not even out of the first graf...

The term seems to have appeared first in the Washington Times in a reference to Islamist fundamentalists. Coined by Khalid Duran, a Muslim scholar seeking to explain Islam to Jews, the word was meant as a criticism of hyper-traditionalist clerics - who in turn denounced Duran as a traitor to the faith.

No wonder the left lost the election in 2004 and possibly beyond. Nothing better to do than to trace a word's origins?

We have nothing for society other than to wreck its institutions, nothing to attract people to our views. So, of course that is the right's fault.

The term Islamofascism is a lamentable word to be sure. Islam is fascism: why give it a sort of indicator that other elements of Islam aren't fascism by saying terrorism is inspired by Islamofascism? Islam is ALL fascism.

Usage has gathered momentum among commentators and academics who seek a verbal missile to debilitate those who disagree with them.

HELP! I'm being oppressed! Someone called me an Islamofascist!

The guy is right. It's terrible when you devote your whole life to wrecking a society whose tit you suck daily.

Words have power over the left because frankly they have nothing else. A lifetime of sedition and treason, and all I got was called an Islamofascist.

They have adopted it as a sort of Judeo-Christian war cry - look for it soon in the title of a neo-conservative think tank conference.

Joe's Islamofascist Institute/Bar and Grill?

For the left, the term "fascist" lost its power in the 1970s, when it was sprayed on every authority figure in sight, from the Nixon-Kissinger White House to university provosts to the neighbourhood cop.

Actually, the obverse is true: The word did have some resonance, but it was overused. But it never really did lose its power. And the word is in widespread usage still in Russia where it essentially got its birth as a disparaging term.

To make Bush-Hitler comparisons work requires more nuanced historical references - to the night of the long knives, for example, as Sidney Blumenthal did about the dismissal of Colin Powell. Unfortunately for liberals, those references donât work as efficiently as islamofascism does for the right, because to imagine the appropriately creepy picture requires a familiarity with German history of the 1920s and 30s. Nazism is better known for its death camps than for Leni Riefenstahl or the Reichstag fire, so analogies between the Nazisâ early years and current Republican party behaviour seem hollow, no matter how strong some parallels might be.

That kool-aid taste good? A little bitter maybe?

Republican party behavior?

Did I miss something? Was there not s'posed to be an example of how 'Republican party behaviour' could even be parallel to the German National Socialist Party at any point in history?

Oh, wait. Nevermind. This is a leftist article about propoganda. I forgot the left often criticizes in ways that smears the left itself with whatever taint-du-jour a befuddled writer can invent.

Christopher Hitchens, a former socialist who now sits on the other end of the political see-saw, sprinkles islamofascism about like paprika.

Hitchens is still very much a creature of the left. I personally like the guy, but he is very much a creature of socialism. His program will resume as soon as the WoT is over.

He and Andrew Sullivan, a voice of the right, both wrongly receive credit in some quarters for coining the term.

How awful. And Sullivan shifted left this last fall. If Sullivan is of the right when John Kerry will run as a republican for senate next time...

Long before September 11 2001, Duran was commissioned by the American Jewish Committee to produce one side of an interfaith project. Duran responded to attacks on his book, Children of Abraham, by deriding those who sought "to impose religious orthodoxy on the state and the citizenry". In that sense, he said, extreme islamism is "islamofascism."

Which was wrong. Islamism IS fascism, no question.

It took a couple of years for the word to seep into frequent usage.

I've used it myself a time or two, but it is too long and I prefer the term Islamowanker anyway.

By then its meaning had expanded. Last year, Sullivan cited "five elements that make it particularly dangerous", including the "broken, medieval societies" that foster it, the "unquenchable extremism" of its motivation, and "the destructive technology" its adherents seek.

Sullivan is a wanker, just like the Guardian writer.

Use of the term to describe Muslim clerics and stateless terrorists has neatly pre-empted any chance of labelling Bush a fascist

Poor baby. All mad coz Bush won't fit into a box?

- no matter how many suspects are kidnapped by the US authorities and tortured;

Cool! That's our spooks, baby!

no matter how impervious the border; no matter how effective the use of propaganda to destroy the opposition;

You must mean the fifth column. The opposition is having a difficult time with their message at the moment, but not the fifth column like this writer.

no matter how many countries are invaded on false pretenses;

You must mean Iraq. You know, that new Bush Imperial province in which there is no democracy, only Bushitlerian fascism.

no matter how strongly a minority religion may become a mark of guilt.

One billion adherants a minority religion? Typical leftist math: 2+2 = 250,000

Thank God f*ckers like this writer don't do engineering.

Posted by badanov 2005-02-04 6:06:55 AM|| [http://www.rkka.org/title-boris.gif] 2005-02-04 6:06:55 AM|| Front Page Top

#5 .com, deep down I think he does get it and knows it fits, & it's eating him up. He's just doing what comes naturally to all candy assed LLL window-lickers w/a masters degree and a third grader's outlook on the world - he's throwing a temper tantrum.

Posted by Jarhead 2005-02-04 9:18:45 AM|| 2005-02-04 9:18:45 AM|| Front Page Top

#6 Hes just pissed because Facism is fullhy applicable to Islam and the Islamic countries such as Iran, Syria, SA, etc... You dont have to look very far for examples.

While Facism is not applicable to Bush. There is no evidence of a 'night of the long knives' or anything else by that matter.

Did anyone notice that the actions of the DNC and its union brownshirts during the last election? Election offices shot at, taken over, and tires slashed. I would not go so far as to call the DNC facists, but they are working on it.

Posted by CrazyFool 2005-02-04 9:28:38 AM|| 2005-02-04 9:28:38 AM|| Front Page Top

#7 The guy obviously wants to have his cake and eat it too: he wants to retain the right to accuse Bush and republicans of being neo-fascists, but try to deny that right to those he opposes.

CrazyFools' remark helped me realize that one of the problems with accusing Bush of being a Fascist/Nazi is that the purported "proof" or "evidence" does not fit the magnitude of the accusation. one of the "outs" Intellectuals use to put down the concept of God is that the claim that God exists is an "extraordinary" claim that demands "extraordinary" proof. The level of proof demanded to prove that one is a murderer is higher than that demanded to prove that one is a pickpocket. No such "extraordinary" evidence exists when it comes to Bush: just highly creative analogies. At the same time, if one substitutes "religious superiority" for "Racial superiority", the correspondence of behavior between Radical Islamists in Sharia and the Nazis becomes easy to make, with an abundance of examples.

To rephrase what CrazyFool said, it pisses this author off that it is easier for us to pin the "Fascist" label on the Islamists than it is for him to pin it on us or on Bush, and he's demanding, like every leftist, a synthetic right of equality of regard and acceptance of one's arguments. He's demanding an intellectual free-lunch, where his arguments are accepted blindly, without any regard to how good they are. Put another way, it's a demand for an Intellectual analogue to federal welfare, in which he gets intellectual currency without having to work for it. Good insight, CF.

Posted by Ptah 2005-02-04 2:30:40 PM|| [http://www.crusaderwarcollege.org] 2005-02-04 2:30:40 PM|| Front Page Top

#8 the best explanation of the historical connections between radical, Qutbist, Islamism and european fascism is found in Paul Berman's "Liberalism and Terror" Berman remains a liberal, and a moderate socialist, but I think most of you would find his insights compelling. And his tone is a lot easier to take than either Hitchens or Sullivan. I strongly recommend this book.

Posted by Liberalhawk 2005-02-04 2:36:01 PM|| 2005-02-04 2:36:01 PM|| Front Page Top

#9 It is "Chimperor Bushitler" as of today.

Posted by Brett 2005-02-04 3:12:04 PM|| 2005-02-04 3:12:04 PM|| Front Page Top

#10 "Christopher Hitchens, a former socialist who now sits on the other end of the political see-saw..."

Um, that's not accurate at all. He is still a socialist (or at least "Third Way," which is socialism for liars), is still not very fond of the US (has he stopped hounding Kissinger yet?), and, in general, is still very much a Leftist.

He is not, however, an Idiotarian. Mr. Scardino is, apparently.

Posted by jackal 2005-02-04 5:30:09 PM|| [http://home.earthlink.net/~sleepyjackal/index.html] 2005-02-04 5:30:09 PM|| Front Page Top

#11 Ptah, Well said!

Posted by phil_b 2005-02-04 5:45:31 PM|| 2005-02-04 5:45:31 PM|| Front Page Top

#12 Ptah has been spot on lately.

Posted by Jules 187 2005-02-04 5:53:39 PM|| 2005-02-04 5:53:39 PM|| Front Page Top

#13 There is no playing the fascist card against Islam, they are fascists.

Posted by Cleans Angereling9543 2005-02-04 6:45:21 PM|| 2005-02-04 6:45:21 PM|| Front Page Top

#14 That which we call "tyrrany" by any other name still smells just as bad.

Posted by Mike 2005-02-04 7:12:10 PM|| 2005-02-04 7:12:10 PM|| Front Page Top

#15 "Islamofascism" is -- at least when I use it -- intended to describe the conflation of racialist nationalism and Islamic fundamentalism. The Baath party is the direct intellectual descendant of the Nazi party! Why is it so hard to follow that? Then you chuck in the tendency of the Islamists to treat Arabs as a kind of master race -- a practice derived either from pan-Arab nationalism or, possibly, from a belief that "the closer you are to Mohammed, the more perfect you are".

CrazyFool and Ptah are right -- this ass is just upset that he can't scream "fascist" and make it stick.

Posted by Robert Crawford 2005-02-04 7:24:03 PM|| [http://www.kloognome.com/] 2005-02-04 7:24:03 PM|| Front Page Top

00:34 Joque Hupique9312
00:34 Joque Hupique9312
00:31 Uneatle Throtle4696
00:31 Uneatle Throtle4696
00:01 trailing wife
00:01 .com
23:49 DMFD
23:47 .com
23:46 Bomb-a-rama
23:44 trailing wife
23:44 Anonymoose
23:42 DMFD
23:39 Mike Sylwester
23:33 Alaska Paul
23:31 3dc
23:27 Alaska Paul
23:25 Alaska Paul
23:18 Alaska Paul
23:09 phil_b
22:54 jackal
22:36 CrazyFool
22:29 Jeamp Ebbereting9472 aka Jarhead
22:22 Jeamp Ebbereting9472 aka Jarhead
22:19 Jeamp Ebbereting9472 aka Jarhead