Article

2004-06-25 Iraq-Jordan

MP Captain Describes Circumstances of Prisonerâs Death

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by Mike Sylwester 2004-06-25 6:31:02 AM|| || Front Page|| [5 views since 2007-05-07] Top

#1 this was a bad business. hard to claim high moral ground if you beat prisoners to death. i feel they shamed the army and made the rest of the good GIs jobs a lot harder.

mortal blow to homefront psychology - deserved or not - US troops have a reputation for not caring about human rights. Annoying because 99.9% of the time they are above board, clean as. This 0.1% have just tarnished the other 99.9% in the minds of the masses all over the world.

And in a democracy it matters what the masses think.

how could they have been so stupid... to take TROPHY PICTURES into the bargain!

I really hope it was an aberration and that it doesn't come out that it was actually sanctioned at the highest levels. warzone or not, HOW you conduct yourself is as important as reaching your objective.

Posted by Anon1 2004-06-25 7:45:52 AM|| 2004-06-25 7:45:52 AM|| Front Page Top

#2 Sounds like the people involved are being charged. What's your beef, Mikey?

Posted by Robert Crawford 2004-06-25 8:19:16 AM|| [http://www.kloognome.com] 2004-06-25 8:19:16 AM|| Front Page Top

#3 Spot on, Anon1--and with the anti-Bush frenzy in the media, that 0.1% is all we're going to hear about until Joe Average thinks it represents the 99.9% as well. *sigh*

Posted by Dar 2004-06-25 9:35:05 AM|| 2004-06-25 9:35:05 AM|| Front Page Top

#4 Anon1, I think you may be conflating different incidents here. Sounds like the SEALs brought in a prisoner who was badly banged up. He subsequently died. Exactly how he got banged up is unknown. You can't leap from that to an assertion of a prison policy to "beat prisoners to death". (Though I'm sure plenty will.) This is a war folks. Operators don't read bad guys their miranda rights and bring them in with velvet handcuffs. Their job is to kill, not detain. No one should be surprised if they bring in someone who is looking worse for wear and tear.

As for the MP staff taking trophy photos with the corpse, that's just plain wrong and is being dealt with. I don't see any news here.

Posted by Classical_Liberal 2004-06-25 12:36:16 PM|| 2004-06-25 12:36:16 PM|| Front Page Top

#5 Joe Average could care less what happens to Iraqi POW's. Joe Average sees Iraqi POW's as the enemy. Joe Average knows that war is brutal and nasty. Joe Average's main concern about this war is body bag counts and it doesn't matter what color panties or other "brutality" that is alleged about our GI's, the only thing Joe Average cares about is how many GI's are killed in a war that Joe Average is having less and less certainty should have been started in the first place. Kapeesh? The WH, the MSM, and some of you are worried about "fair play" in war and Joe Average has far more common sense, he is more pragmatic.

If George Bush loses the election because of the Iraq War[btw, polls show him leading Kerry by 7 points this week because the economy is picking up]it's not going to be because of POW abuse. It will be because of a)the Iraqi's actions-their lack of gratitude and support of what we have done for them and b) because Joe Average has zero interest in this experimental theory of solving terrorism by playing Johnny Appleseed with democracy thruout the hellholes of the world and getting American boys killed and maimed in the process.

Posted by rex 2004-06-25 12:40:25 PM|| 2004-06-25 12:40:25 PM|| Front Page Top

09:24 Anonymous5417
11:43 Raptor
11:37 rkb
11:32 rkb
11:23 too true
10:16 Edward Yee
10:02 Edward Yee
10:01 Edward Yee
09:29 Rafael
02:52 Quana
02:49 Super Hose
02:45 Super Hose
00:28 Lucky
00:26 George
00:23 Anonymous2U
00:04 smn
00:00 gromky
23:54 Silentbrick
23:49 smn
23:38 RWV
23:37 smn
23:33 A Jackson
23:30 SteveS
23:30 Barbara Skolaut