Archived material Access restricted Article
Rantburg

Today's Front Page   View All of Sun 12/31/2006 View Sat 12/30/2006 View Fri 12/29/2006 View Thu 12/28/2006 View Wed 12/27/2006 View Tue 12/26/2006 View Mon 12/25/2006
1
2006-12-31 Iraq
Genghis Khan: Law and order
Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.
Posted by Steve White 2006-12-31 00:51|| || Front Page|| [2 views since 2007-05-07]  Top

#1 A bit of political spin on this article, histories I have read give a very different perspective on Baghdad after the Mongols, from Wikipedia, for lack of a better source:
The Mongols swept into [Baghdad] on February 13 [1257] and began a week of massacre, looting, rape, and destruction.
As far as damage done, the sack of Baghdad by the Mongols made the sack of Rome by Alaric look kindly. The Grand Library of Baghdad, containing countless precious historical documents and books on subjects ranging from medicine to astronomy, was destroyed. Survivors said that the waters of the Tigris ran black with ink from the enormous quantities of books flung into the river. Citizens attempted to flee, but were intercepted by Mongol soldiers who raped and killed with abandon.
Although death counts vary widely and cannot be easily substantiated, a number of estimates do exist. Martin Sicker writes that close to 90,000 people may have died (Sicker 2000, p. 111). Other estimates go much higher. Muslim historian Abdullah Wassaf claims the loss of life was several hundred thousand or more. Ian Frazier of The New Yorker says estimates of the death toll have ranged from 200,000 to a million.
The Mongols looted and then destroyed. Mosques, palaces, libraries, hospitals — grand buildings that had been the work of generations were burned to the ground. ... Prior to this, the Mongols destroyed a city only if it had resisted them. Cities that capitulated at the first demand for surrender could usually expect to be spared. Cities that surrendered after a short fight, such as this, normally could expect a sack, but not complete devastation. The utter ferocity of the rape of Baghdad is the worst example of Mongol excess known. ...[From the article "once the takeover ended, the bloodshed ended." -- probably because there was no one left to kill! The Mongols "exercised a genius for speaking to people in terms that they understood." Everybody understands "Submit or die!"]
Baghdad was a depopulated, ruined city for several centuries... Of all the Mongol Khans, [Hulagu] is, for obvious reasons, the most feared and despised.
Aftermath
Thus was the caliphate destroyed, and Mesopotamia ravaged — it has never again been such a major center of culture and influence. ...[due to a succession crisis] after 1258 there was no unified Mongol Empire, but four separate kingdoms, including the Il-Khanate of Persia established by Hulagu. [The world conquered by the Mongols was a good deal smaller than the real one, and their unified rule extremely brief in historical terms.]
In the meantime, the Mongols led by Kitbuqa had fallen out with the crusaders holding the coast of Palestine, and the Mamluks were able to ally with them [the crusaders, that is], pass through their territory, and destroy the Mongol army at the Battle of Ain Jalut. {This was the first significant defeat of Mongol armies and ensured the security of Egypt from the Mongols.} Palestine and Syria were permanently lost, the border remaining the Tigris for the duration of Hulagu's dynasty.
[After the succession crisis was resolved in Mongolia] Hulagu returned to his [newly conquered] lands [near Iraq] by 1262, but instead of being able to avenge his defeats, was drawn into civil war with Batu Khan's brother Berke.

Berke, a Muslim, sternly protested Hulagu's destruction of Baghdad. Berke allied himself with the Mamluks and started raiding Hulagu's forces in the area of the Caucasus, inflicting a severe defeat on him in 1263. Hulagu died in 1265. The centuries-old irrigation system of Mesopotamia fell into ruins and has not been replaced. In the mid 1300's several outbreaks of the Black Death kicked the remnants of Iraq while they were down. In 1401 Baghdad resisted its Mongol/Turkic rule and the infamous Tamerlane ravaged it yet again. One account recalls he commanded his veterans to bring back two severed human heads from the populace and stack them in one of 120 skull pyramids around the city, The stink of rotting human flesh carried for miles. Now that's shock and awe. Modern propagandists attempt to minimize the godawful destruction which fell on Baghdad between 1257 and 1401 by equating it with the two wars in Iraq between 1990 and now. Modern day deniers state that Muslims have exaggerated the terrific destruction brought on Iraq by the Mongols and the Black Death in their politically-motivated campaign to denigrate the current US war effort there. To state
Iraq enjoyed a century of peace and a renaissance that brought the region to a level of prosperity and cultural sophistication higher than it enjoyed before or after.
is a gross distortion.
Posted by Anguper Hupomosing9418 2006-12-31 03:12||   2006-12-31 03:12|| Front Page Top

#2 I read a Sufi text years back which stated the original "Assassins" were actually a Sufi sect that spread the false rumor that they would send out suicide killers against those who threatened the order. Opportunists jumped on the bandwagon & soon every assassination in the middle East was blamed on the "Assassins", who of course were always killed immediately after completing their mission. The middle East has always had an abundance of suicide killers, anyway. The original sect was so successful in scaring their opponents they were mostly left alone until the Mongols showed up. No real "Assassins" were ever dispatched, the rumor alone protected the sect. Makes a great story, anyway.
Posted by Anguper Hupomosing9418 2006-12-31 04:57||   2006-12-31 04:57|| Front Page Top

#3 Excerpt from the book "Storm from the East" by Robert Marshall:

The Mongols' prime objective was the Caliph of Baghdad, but before confronting him they meant to eliminate the other major power in the region, The Ismailis or Assassins. They had emerged because of a schism in the Shia Muslim sect and established themselves in northern and eastern Persia by taking and controlling a series of mountain fortifications. Behind their walls they lived a contemplative life, producing beautifully wrought paintings and metalworks, but beyond their retreats they terrorized those civilizations they deemed heretical and so earned the enmity not just of the rest of the Islamic world but eventually of Europe. Rather than confronting his enemies in open combat he preferred to sponsor a campaign of political murder, usually executed with a dagger in the back, as the means to his ends.

The Mongols has their own reasons for launching a campaign against the Assassins. First, they had received a plea of help from an Islamic judge in Qaswin, a town near the Assassins' stronghold at Alamut, who had complained that his fellow citizens were forced to wear armour all the time as protection from the Assassins' daggers. According to Rubruck, another reason that determined Mongol attitudes was the discovery of a plot to send no fewer than 400 dagger-wielding Assassins in disguise to Qaraqorum with the instructions to murder the Great Khan. The Assassins had encountered the Mongols once before, during Chormaghun's terror raid through northern Persia 1237-8, which led them to send an envoy to Europe to beg help.

...

On 1 January 1256 Hulegu's army crossed the Oxus River and brought into Persia the most formidable war machine ever seen. It possessed the very latest in siege engineering, gunpowder from China, catapults that would send balls of flaming naphtha into their enemy's cities, and divisions of rigorously trained mounted archers led by generals who had learnt their skills at the feet of Genghis Khan and Subedei. As news of Hulegu's army spread he was soon presented with a succession of sultans, emirs, and atabaks from as far apart as Asia Minor and Herat, all come to pay homage. Its sheer presence brought to an end nearly forty years of rebellion and unrest in the old lands of Khwarazmia, but to the inhabitants of Persia and Syria it was the dawn of a new world order.

The Mongols made first for the Elburz Mountains where the Assassins lay in wait behind what they believed to be their impregnable fortresses. With extraordinary ingenuity the Mongol generals and their Chinese engineers manoeuvred their artillery up the mountain slopes and set them up around the walls of the fortress of Alamut. But before the order was given to commence firing the Assassins' Grand Master, Rukn ad_Din signaled that he wanted to negotiate. Hulegu countered that he must immediately order the destruction of his own fortifications; when Rukn ad_Din prevaricated; the bombardment commenced. Under the most devastatingly accurate fire, the walls quickly tumbled and Rukn ad_Din surrendered. Hulegu took him prisoner, transported him to every Assassin castle they confronted, and paraded him before each garrison with the demand for an immediate surrender. Some obliged, as at Alamut; while others, like Gerdkuh, had to be taken by force. Today the spherical stone missiles fired by the artillery teams at the walls still litter the perimeter of the ruins. Whether each 'eagle's nest' surrendered or taken, the Mongols put all the inhabitants to the swords - even the women in their homes and the babies in their cradles.

As the slaughter continued, Rukn ad_Din begged Hulegu to allow him to go to Qaraqorum where he would pay homage to the great Khan and plead for clemency. Hulegu agreed, but when he got to Qaraqorum Mongke Khan refused to see him. It was effectively a sentence of death. On the journey back his Mongol escorts turned on the Grand Master and his attendants, who were 'kicked to a pulp'. The Persian historian Juvaini commented that 'the world had been cleansed'. Five hundred years later Edward Gibbon echoed those sentiments, claiming that the Mongols' campaign 'may be considered as a service to mankind'. It took two years for the Mongols to dislodge over 200 'eagle's nests', but in the process they virtually expunged the Assassins from Persia.
Posted by Procopius2k 2006-12-31 07:53||   2006-12-31 07:53|| Front Page Top

#4 IN HIS FINAL televised speech to the Iraqi people in 2003, Saddam Hussein denounced the invading Americans as "the Mongols of this age," a reference to the last time infidels had conquered his country, in 1258.

The British conquered the place in the Great War; I expect they count as infidels. Of course, it cost them 92,000 men to drive out the Turks. I do not have an estimate for the Mongol version but I expect it made the "slow motion massacre" of the last few years look like a church picnic.
Posted by Excalibur 2006-12-31 10:30||   2006-12-31 10:30|| Front Page Top

#5 "If that were true, not two scorched stones of your fine house would be standing atop one another."
Posted by mojo">mojo  2006-12-31 12:23||   2006-12-31 12:23|| Front Page Top

#6 So what does history teach us ?
Everything, it depends on whose history.
Posted by wxjames 2006-12-31 18:06||   2006-12-31 18:06|| Front Page Top

#7 Genghis Khan (not Conan) said: "The greatest joy a man can know is to conquer his enemies and drive them before him. To ride their horses and take away their possessions. To see the faces of those who were dear to them bedewed with tears, and to clasp their wives and daughters in his arms"

I.e. kill, pillage and rape. That the Mongols did in Baghdad. Not a lot of administering.
Posted by ed 2006-12-31 23:10||   2006-12-31 23:10|| Front Page Top

23:51 Barbara Skolaut
23:18 tu3031
23:17 Free Radical
23:10 ed
22:41 CrazyFool
21:53 bruce
21:50 Zhang Fei
21:47 Frank G
21:39 Frank G
21:17 Chuck Darwin
21:17 twobyfour
21:10 gromgoru
21:08 Elmert Crosh5077
21:04 gromgoru
21:04 Frank G
21:00 Jackal
20:59 gromgoru
20:58 Jackal
20:58 Mike N.
20:54 Frank G
20:48 Mike N.
20:48 Sherry
20:43 Barbara Skolaut
20:38 49 Pan









Paypal:
Google
Search WWW Search rantburg.com