Article

2007-09-15 Home Front: WoT

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by lotp 2007-09-15 10:15|| || Front Page|| [7 views ] Top
File under: Global Jihad

#1 A World order based on Tolkien---now I've seen everything.

Posted by gromgoru 2007-09-15 12:20|| 2007-09-15 12:20|| Front Page Top

#2 *sigh*

The guy is a liberal idiot using Tolkien's work in the same way that liberals always have perverted other people's works to further their own ends.

The "Shire Strategy" he's advocating is for the West to Build Walls and Hunker Down. Someone truly familiar with the triology would realize that that was King Theoden's strategy at Helm's Deep: THAT didn't work out. What is ironic is that, although the Hobbits would have agreed that a "Hunker Down" policy would have been their preference, the destruction of the One Ring required that a few brave Hobbits NOT HUNKER DOWN IN THE SHIRE. The presence of Hobbits outside of the Shire was necessary, not only to save the Shire, but also the entire West. If one is inclined to press the analogy, then The Scouring of the Shire (left out in the movie) that actually delivered the Shire was instigated and led by those Hobbits that DIDN'T stay in the Shire, which seems to imply that those fighting Islam outside of America will return to deliver it.

The author deliberately conflates The One Ring with Universalism, Nuclear weapons, or anything else that would truly prove decisive against the enemy. What he does NOT advocate is direct confrontation with Islam, casting it as if it was one of Tolkein's Races of the West, rather than an entirely separate set of races led by Sauron, intent on destroying the Races of the West. The fatal flaw of keeping the ring to use against Sauron was that, in using it, they kept Sauron alive. They had to destroy the ring, not to make Sauron give up his mad dreams of world domination and adopt a "live-and-let-live" attitude, but to DESTROY SAURON himself. The shire survived, not by hunkering down, but through the West's determination to achieve total victory.

Part of the problem with the ring was that its appearance deceived the people around it: just because it looked like a ring, they thought it was JUST a ring. All the other rings served their wearers, why not this one? The problem was that so much of Sauron was in the ring that the ring became the master: that was the only way Sauron could make sure the ring could not be used against him. Even the Elrond Council was in the dark about how powerful the Ring was, thinking that its power would not affect a Hobbit, a race that did not receive the other rings.

What IS the equivalent of the ring today? Actually, I think there is no such thing, being a side-effect of trying to apply Tolkien's tale too broadly or literally: The Islamic equivalent of Sauron would be the Caliph, but there is no Caliph, so the analogy falls down there too. To my mind, the Ring is whatever the Enemy desperately requires to hang on and eventually win. Not destroying it, but trying to use it on your own behalf merely keeps the Enemy alive, if subdued. Using the Ring against Sauron may have appeared on paper as a Good strategy, but it was the enemy of the Best Strategy: destroying it, and Sauron, forever.

This is not to say that Tolkein's tale does not hold lessons for us. It does:

There ARE some things worth fighting for, and your homeland is one of them.

Active Offense is better than Passive Defense.

Fighting the enemy Over There is better than fighting the enemy Here.

There is no substitute for Total Victory.

And there are no shortcuts to True Victory.

Posted by Ptah">Ptah 2007-09-15 20:57|| http://www.crusaderwarcollege.org]">[http://www.crusaderwarcollege.org] 2007-09-15 20:57|| Front Page Top

#3 *happy sigh* I do love when you think aloud, Ptah.

Posted by trailing wife 2007-09-15 22:28|| 2007-09-15 22:28|| Front Page Top

23:59 Boss Craising2882
23:55 Zenster
23:53 Zenster
23:16 SR-71
23:02 SR-71
23:02 Zenster
22:59 Zenster
22:44 Zenster
22:31 Zenster
22:28 trailing wife
21:50 Jimmy Carter
21:42 McZoid
21:30 Valentine
21:27 gorb
20:58 mrp
20:57 Ptah
20:48 twobyfour
20:44 Frank G
20:40 lotp
20:39 lotp
20:36 twobyfour
20:25 mrp
20:19 Zenster
20:16 Duh!